Brett Favre. Easily
Chad Pennigton. Even More so.
Peyton Manning. If you can Defend, and Run....
Jeff Garcia. Same Type of Player, Better QB.
Mike Vick. Cmon....
Brett Favre. Easily Chad Pennigton. Even More so.
Peyton Manning. If you can Defend, and Run....
Jeff Garcia. Same Type of Player, Better QB.
Mike Vick. Cmon....
I'll agree with Favre & Manning. Pennington is obviously good but hasn't played enough & hasn't accomplished anything. Same with Vick.
I've never liked Garcia for some reason. I don't think he would do better than McNabb if he played for Philly. I would also add McNair.