To: Mr. Silverback
As for Copernicuss sudden flash of insight, Stark quotes the eminent historian L. Bernard Cohen who called that idea an invention of later historians. Copernicus was taught the essential fundamentals leading to his model by his Scholastic professorsthat is, Christian scholars. That model was developed gradually by a succession of . . . Scholastic scientists over the previous two centuries. Building upon their work on orbital mechanics, Copernicus added the implicit next step. uummmm NO! If that were the case then why did they later burn Giordano Bruno at the stake for espousing the Copernican theory?
40 posted on
12/04/2003 1:23:31 PM PST by
qam1
(@Starting Generation X Ping list - Freep me to be added and see my home page for details)
To: qam1
I've seen Bruno described as a "neoplatonist mystic" but I've never seen any evidence that he was burned for defending Copernicus.
44 posted on
12/04/2003 1:46:36 PM PST by
Varda
To: qam1
Bruno was burned for witchcraft, not for his cosmological ideas.
46 posted on
12/04/2003 2:03:23 PM PST by
Campion
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson