Posted on 07/10/2022 8:34:05 PM PDT by DoodleBob
RED LION, Pa. — Signs and flags emblazoned with the phrase “Let’s Go Brandon” and the stronger-language phrase it substitutes for aren’t an uncommon sight in Central Pennsylvania yards and on cars.
Flying a flag with the “F” word on it offends some, while others, like Melissa Low of Mount Wolf, are concerned about its impact on kids.
“No matter your political opinion, I don’t think it needs to be that vulgar,” she said.
One can debate whether the phrase is in bad taste, but there’s likely no legal basis to remove them.
Free speech does have some limits; for example, the Supreme Court has ruled obscenity is not protected.
“But what the Supreme Court means by obscenity in that context is not swear words. It’s hard-core pornography,” said Michael Dimino, a law professor at Widener Law Commonwealth.
The “F” word could qualify as obscenity in certain contexts if its use “appeals to the prurient interest,” meaning the language is overly sexual. In that context, displaying a sign with the “F” word could violate a Pennsylvania law banning the display of obscenity.
In the case of “Let’s Go Brandon” and the phrase it represents, the “F” word instead has a distinctly political meaning. Political speech is the most protected form of speech in the Constitution.
“It may be vulgar. It may be obscene. It may be hate speech,” said attorney Mark Scaringi of Scaringi Law. “But the slogan is protected by the First Amendment.”
After seeing a few such signs in Red Lion Borough, FOX43 reached out to borough officials. The borough solicitor said the speech would be protected even if residents complained, though one borough official said he had not heard of any complaints.
Just because the signs are legal, though, doesn’t mean they’re appreciated by neighbors.
“I think people do have a right to put what they want in their yard,” Low said. “But I just don’t feel that it needs to be vulgar and something that’s negative for the community.”
As if nobody had a “F___ Donald Trump” sign.
That Leftists and the Woke get offended should be celebrated!
How could this possibly be obscene? Brandon himself said it, while Jill was seated next to him.
I agree. I love that it annoys them.
And they can whine all they want; the beauty of “Let’s Go Brandon” is that there is no profanity at all.
We all know what it stands for, but the phrase itself is a clean as a whistle. 😁
It was and still is much more vulgar against President Trump. Quit lying, beoich.
Kind of like when you tell someone, “Bless your heart.”
I saw so many Buck Fush bumper stickers around DC I lost count..
The first person who says the first person who curses loses is the person who has no argument.
Try to imagine what would happen if Joe Biden ever stood before a large unscreened crowd or rally.
Try to imagine what would happen if Joe Biden ever stood before a large unscreened crowd or rally.
What? Seriously? Fookin’ idjits.
Did Biden just say the equivalent of we know where you live?
Did they pull Attorney Scragini out of the phone book to offer an opinion? “…It may be hate speech.” could you please explain that one, counsel, with specific reference to specific hate speech statutes. Simpleton
The NBC gal who came out with that phrase the first time should have trademarked it and quit her job, she’d have been a millionaire by now.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.