Skip to comments.MLB umpires agree to electronic strike zone testing and development for 'robot umps' in new union deal
Posted on 12/22/2019 4:47:19 AM PST by Libloather
click here to read article
My weakness, constancy on the low strike. We were supposed to do top off the knee, but most wanted us center knee.
Remember if you take the inside edge of the ball on the outside edge of the plate that makes the zone about 5 inches wider than the plate.
I hate the idea of each umpire havig their own zone. That was supposed to go away but it’s worse now IMO.
They need to put a few of these guys out to pasture too. I don’t need to know the umpire’s name.
Personally, I dont like, and have never liked, replays in sports.
Back in the middle of the last century - before all the fancy ways the computer tells us how to bat & throw, it was ‘breaking your wrist’ to determine whether it was a checked swing or not OR if your wrist ‘rolled over’ it was a swing.
You are correct though that it does appear to get called even though wrists not rolled but head of bat is ahead of body.....or something like that.. <: <: <:
In 1969 it was not break your wrist. It was the position of the bat and how far it went over the plate.
It is adjusted according to the batter. Its from roughly the knee to just above the letters on the shirt. For a shorter batter, its a shorter zone.
Guess with the advent of baseball players ‘working out’ etc made their wrists stronger and were able to go all the way around without rolling their wrists...
When I first started playing ball we wore caps to the plate. I remember the first ‘helmet’ was two pieces of hard plastics over the ear connected with an ‘elastic’ band.
I was wearing one when I squared around to bunt and had a pitch hit me in the cheek area as I was turning my head away from an inside pitch, driving the device off of me.
I became a fan...sorta..
I am inclined to overthink this, but it appears the vertical zone is in play according to batter, but the horizontal is not. The width of home plate, which never changes, will determine (for lack of better words) the east-west zone. I would be interested in a 3D depiction of a strike zone, and find it a bit surprising that it would change from one batter to the next, but that makes sense now that i overthink about it..
Only if we get robot managers who are allowed to argue the logarithms, etc
I believe you are referring to algorithms.
Except that MLB umps are PROUD to have their own individual strike zones. They don’t even TRY. “My strike zone” is a phrase with them. There’s plenty of consistency, in their ego, and their willingness to ignore the rule book and decide for themselves what a strike zone is. Which is why good pitchers study the umps.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.