The Breaking Of The Never Trump Mind
Christopher Bedford
FTA:
...At 2016s cocktail parties, the party of Donald Trump was decidedly less welcome. There were no calls for unity this time around, nor many offered in return.
When Jeb Bush touted his brothers record on keeping Americans safe, Trump didnt pay homage to the last Republican president. The World Trade Center came down during your brothers reign, he replied. Remember that.
The professional Republican audience booed loudly, and professional journalists were aghast. But elsewhere, it rang true.
I became Trumps biggest fan, J.D. Vance, a Marine and the author of Hillbilly Elegy, wrote. I wanted him to go for the jugular. I wanted him to inquire whom, precisely, George W. Bush had kept safe. Was it the veterans lingering in a bureaucratic quagmire at the Department of Veterans Affairs or the victims of 9/11? Was it the enlistees from my block back home, who signed their lives on the dotted line while Jebs brother told the country to go shoppingsomething kids like me couldnt afford to do?
Trump was not the origin of the discontent, Kesler writes, however vital he was to its crystallization.
When Trump debated Hillary Clinton on the border, he didnt color his language with act of love or apologies for our law. We have some bad hombres, he told the country, and were going to get them out.
The professionals were aghast. Large swathes of the country, however, agreed with him.
And that very night, when Clinton went on the offensive on abortion, conservatives might have expected more of the familiar Republican defenses: an oath of fealty to womens rights followed by a nonthreatening confession of religious belief, finished with an agreement to disagree because its the law of the land or some such platitudes. Instead, in an arena in the Las Vegas desert, the New York businessman hit harder than any presidential candidate in memory: Based on what shes saying, and based on where shes going and where shes been, Trump began, you can take the baby and rip the baby out of the womb in the ninth month on the final day. And thats not acceptable.
Such a nasty woman.
Somewhere in Georgetown, the professional class may have blanched, but at Stoneys Rockin Country cowboy bar on a highway outside the security parameter, a crowd of truckers, mothers, postmen and real estate agents erupted.
Trump identified with working men and women, and promised (at least) to add jobs, to boost economic growth, to win for pipe-fitters and waitresses, too, Kesler writes. He defended their Social Security but blasted the fraud of Obamacare, whereas Romney had scorned the 47%s entitlements but gave Obamacare (based, you may recall, on Romneycare) a pass.
Romney hit every bell the donor class asked for: Successful governor in a blue state, successful businessman, success of the Winter Olympics; religious but not too religious, conservative but pragmatic, and, paradoxically, seemingly willing to stay in Iraq until it had democracy and a middle class.
Romney, Kesler muses, lacked perhaps what Kanye West would call dragon energy.
The Never Trumpers say they dont recognize a Republican Party where the core tenets are neither free trade nor foreign democracy promotion. But maybe they just didnt know their voters by sight, because the only party that has truly departed recognition is Never Trump.
Each week brings this movement a new and bizarre position: Opposing tax cuts, supporting Obamacare; wishing North Korean talks ill, wishing Democratic investigators well; dreaming of European political meddling, pining for American political comeuppance.
Rick Santorum, the Catholic working-class firebrand rarely seen among Washingtons polite classes, had long commented that a party such as the GOP, with a donor class so out of line with its base, could not possibly continue to function.
There could not be such a massive realignment without something somewhere snapping, but despite the Never Trump hysteria, it doesnt appear to be the party. Though the presidents House was defeated in the first post-Trump national elections and his two-year approval among Democrats lies at historic lows, his approval with his own votersthose who the Never Trumpers courted not long agois second only to George W. Bush after 9/11.
As the second year of Trumps presidency ends, these former Republicans have insulted and alienated their readers until they had none. Theyve squandered their time on unimportant, self-righteous panel discussions, finally reduced to bobbing up in partisan anti-Trump venues surrounded by men and women who called them war criminals just years before, buoyed for a time by saying the right thing about the right enemy.
NAFTA, mean words and Donald Trump cannot possibly be the origin of these shattered minds, however vital those were to the breaking.
Really great article, Mairdie. I’ve passed it along. Hopefully “Gross George” Conway (Kellyanne) will read it as well! Thanks.
Thanks for posting.