Casey and Haley peform together, singing "I Feel The Earth Move"
Why? This would have been a great song for either one of them to sing individually. But the show (yet again) has 90 minutes to fill, so this is better than a group song of Idol rejects, I guess.
They do sound great together.
Will they be critiqued on this?
Sorta. Just a few words from Steven Tyler.
Steven: How much in love with Haley are you? That was really good. There wasn't anything about that I didn't like. Gorgeous. It was great. Nothing I didn't like.