Natch, when they mentioned Carole King, they were speaking my language and sparked the nostalgia...*sigh*...
So, how about:
Haley, “[Do the] LocoMotion” or “Where You Lead, I Will Follow”
Casey, “I Feel the Earth Move” or “Smackwater Jack” or “Jazzman”
Lauren, “One Fine Day”
Scotty, “It’s Too Late” or “So Far Away”
Jacob, “So Far Away” or “Been to Canaan” or “Way Over Yonder” (lots of material for Jacob here...)
James, “You’ve Got a Friend” or “Up on the Roof”
Good choices but I think Haley is made for “I feel Thr earth move” and Lauren would kill with “will you still love me tomorrow”.
I could see Casey with “jazz man” too or “up on the roof.”
Scotty cannot carry off “it’s too late” about a long failed relationship. He s too young.