Will--Needs to sing something with more vigor than that. He's bland to begin with and singing something as mellow as James Taylor is just the wrong thing for him to do.
Taylor--Difficult to say on this one. The song has energy but it strikes me as a soul-less energy. Taylor needs to let Gedeon pick his songs for him.
Gedeon--I think his stock will continue to rise with this.
Kevin--Don McLean songs seem like a good choice for him, but I don't think Don McLean songs are well-liked enough boost his position.
Chris--Don't know the song. Figure if he keeps doing what he's been doing, he's safe to advance though.
Ace--Would like to see him attempt a masculine performance. Doesn't look like it's going to happen tonight with that song.
Elliot--Think he could sing any song pretty well. His voice is different enough from Bryan Adams that he could make the song his own if he can bring some passion to it.
Bucky--Hanging on by his fingernails. Needs a big performance tonight.
Three most in danger of leaving:
Bucky(Doesn't have the talent. Doesn't have the "cuteness" appeal that the other two have going for them. Bet he's gone.)
Will(Actually has a nice voice. He's a bit dull though. Too bad he wasn't from the Donny Osmond era. I could see him on the cover of "Tiger Beat" from the late 60's-early 70's. Think he's probably gone.)
Kevin(Idol has been ragging on him pretty bad the past couple of weeks. I think it's going to have stirred up enough sympathy vote to keep him on especially if he gets teased again tonight. If someone is kicking a puppy, the puppy is going to be defended even if the puppy is goofy looking.)
Hey! What a great idea!! Let them draw names and pick songs for each other. Can't be any worse. :) Could be fun.