Their best makeover was Clay, and they've kind of gone downhill from there.
I'm shocked no one did 'Rock Around the Clock' by Bill Haley and the Comets. I'm listening to it as I type this. It's the first true rock anthem and is still a joy to listen to. Maybe AI doesn't have the rights to use the song. But rock and roll was born in the 50's, and you'd think the teen and 20-something contestants would love to do some classic rock.
Well you have to admit with Clay there was nowhere to go but up. :) Clay had a nice face at least to work with, Kevin needs to mature a little before they can really work with him.