[blueriver]

The court did not refuse to make rulings based upon supposition, innuendo, and unfounded allegations. This is exactly what they did - they made a ruling that Terri did not want water because her husband, HIS brother, and HIS brothers wife said that is what she said. If that is not a ruling on suppositions I don't know what is. They also threw out other testimony that Terri said she did not agree with the feeding tube being removed from Kathleen Quinlin.

[lugsoul]

People here keep using this specious term "threw out evidence" - the court DID NOT "throw out" that evidence - it received it, considered it, and found it to be less credible than the countervailing evidence. Since you didn't hear the testimony in court, you have no way of determining the soundness of that decision, or lack thereof.