Posted on 11/17/2026 9:25:02 AM PST by Red Badger
A federal court struck down a Trump administration rule that would have placed significant restrictions on the number of years international students could lawfully study in the United States on Monday.
The final rule would have replaced the longstanding “Duration of Status” system with a four-year fixed admission period for F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors, and their dependents. In a Nov. 16 memorandum, U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts Judge Dennis Saylor wrote that the Department of Homeland Security policy was “arbitrary and capricious.”
The Penn community does “not need to take any new action as a result of this ruling,” Penn International Student and Scholar Services Executive Director Rudie Altamirano wrote in a statement.
“Because further legal proceedings are possible, International Student and Scholar Services will continue to monitor developments and provide timely guidance as the situation evolves,” he added.
“If the media really cared about legitimate international students, they would be thanking President Trump for cracking down on the rampant fraud to ensure only those truly intending to study in the United States are given the privilege,” a Homeland Security spokesperson wrote in a statement.
Saylor wrote that the proposed rule would “effectively prohibit” a student seeking a degree at “the same or lower level as the one he or she has completed” from entering the country — even though DHS itself acknowledged that there were “legitimate reasons” why one might do so.
In October 2025, Penn sent a letter to DHS opposing the policy. At the time, administrators wrote that the policy would undermine “competitiveness” in American education, disrupt “virtually all” Ph.D. programs, and impose “significant administrative costs” on both students and universities.
According to the court’s ruling, the federal government “failed to account” for provisions in the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System that could be used to achieve the same goals as the proposed “Final Rule.” Saylor referenced previous examples of SEVIS being used to “identify cases of abuse” — such as instances of “pay-to-stay” fraud.
The proposed system, Saylor wrote, is “unreviewable,” “completely discretionary,” and does not “adequately” explain how it would improve efforts to address fraud.
“At the very least, DHS should have carefully weighed the costs and benefits of enhancements to the SEVIS system against the immense costs and limited benefits of the Final Rule, which it failed to do,” Saylor wrote.
Under current regulations, most F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors are admitted under Duration of Status policies, which allow them to remain in the United States for the length of their academic or exchange program if they maintain their immigration status. Under the proposed rule, admissions would have instead expired on a specific date, and individuals who required additional time to complete their program would need to file an Extension of Stay application.
“Come on a student visa, take one class per semester, and stay here for decades,” Department of Homeland Security General Counsel James Percival wrote in a statement. “According to Judge Dennis Saylor, ICE must permit this rampant abuse of our immigration system.”
Saylor wrote that the department’s actions were “contrary to statutory authority” because the power of “setting terms of entry” belongs to Congress, not executive agencies. While such agencies are granted the power to “set the ‘time’ and ‘conditions’ of nonimmigrants’ stay,” he added, the proposed rule was “not reasonably related to that purpose.”
“Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity — providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States — that Congress sought to permit and encourage,” Saylor wrote. “The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program.”
Other guidance regarding international student enrollment — such as requests for Curricular Practical Training authorization — remains in place. In September, international students at the University told The Daily Pennsylvanian that mounting uncertainty was already reshaping their career plans.
=========================================================================
Senior reporter Lavanya Mani covers legal affairs and can be reached at mani@thedp.com. At Penn, she studies comparative literature. Follow her on X @LavanyaMani_.
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
Judge Roy Bean days are back.
Will be overturned. It went through the normal rule making process and is neither arbitrary nor capricious. The Judge’s opinion is an abuse of discretion.
Of the three co-equal branches of our government, the Judicial branch has the most power (near infinite) and the Executive branch (when a Republican is in charge) has by far the least amount of allowed power. It’s a system of checks and balances to make sure Democrats always have control.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F._Dennis_Saylor_IV
. . .He later was a special counsel and chief of staff to Robert Mueller, then assistant attorney general of the Criminal Division at the United States Department of Justice, from 1990 to 1993.
While at Goodwin Procter, Saylor represented Circor International, Inc., KF Industries, Inc., and senior company officials as a criminal defense attorney while those companies were under investigation for smuggling Chinese-manufactured valves and selling the valves as a product of the U.S. between 2001 and 2004.[1] The U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, Michael T. Shelby, dismissed the investigation days after Saylor was confirmed by the Senate.
It’s a big club and Trump ain’t in it!...................
It’s now axiomatic that if something good is happening a single judge will declare dominion over the whole US and order it stopped.
The USSC and Congress choose not to rein it in. Without blathering they must this or we oughtta that, that’s where things stand.
What does that tell you about the legal system where one jumps through hoops, goes to a higher court and enriches lawyers every step of the way? A panel of common sense citizens could handle it cheaper. There will be some lefty loons on that panel but look at the voter ID issue. Should it be handled by the senate?
There’s too much common sense stuff where opinions need not be heard, just voted on.
This is either up to Congress to fix by legislation (Congress has unlimited power to fix this problem), or up to the Executive to fix by partial or complete State of Exception.
Since neither of those things are happening, this isn’t getting fixed any time soon.
Saylor also waited till Biden could replace him, not Trump.
A Smirking Chimp playa for Team Donk...
The United States isn’t a serious country any more.
The Supreme Court is not the boss of Circuit and District judges, except that IF their ruling makes it in front of the USSC, the USSC can overrule theirs and either resolve the case themselves or refer it back for further proceedings.
The vast majority of these decisions are not accepted for review, and in fact the USSC could not possibly review them all.
Congress, OTOH, has absolute supremacy over Circuit and District Courts. They can create new ones, abolish old ones, limit their jurisdiction, and impeach their judges.
The one thing Congress cannot do is stop payment to judges with lifetime appointments.
That Congress has never done what they CAN do to resolve this issue means that they are fine with not fixing it.
How about no more student visas. Problem solved.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.