Posted on 11/16/2026 3:24:54 PM PST by UMCRevMom@aol.com
I said something on my Saturday morning radio show that may surprise a few of my conservative friends. Not everyone who disagrees with us is a lunatic. I know. Shocking stuff coming from a fellow who spent decades working alongside Rush Limbaugh and has never been particularly shy about his political opinions. But I meant it. A wonderful caller named Isabel from Long Island was sharing her concerns about the direction of the country. She was worried about the Supreme Court, the policies Democrats might pursue and the consequences of putting more liberal politicians in positions of power. I understood her concerns. In fact, I share quite a few of them. But then she described many of the people voters had elected as lunatics. And that’s where I had to disagree.“I don’t think people are lunatics,” I told her. “I think people act on the information that they have.”
Now, before anybody starts checking to see whether somebody slipped something into my morning coffee, allow me to explain. I think Bernie Sanders is wrong about an enormous number of things. I think Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has embraced economic ideas that could do tremendous damage to this country. I have serious disagreements with the Democratic Party over taxation, immigration, government spending and the role of Washington in our everyday lives. But that doesn’t mean everybody who supports those ideas is crazy. It means we disagree. Sometimes fundamentally. And if we’re going to persuade people that CONSERVATIVE IDEAS are better, we might want to start by understanding what they’re actually asking for.
TAKE HEALTH CARE. The progressive left wants Medicare for All. They believe government should guarantee health coverage to everybody, and many argue that a single-payer system is the best way to accomplish that. I have enormous concerns about the costs, the bureaucracy and the consequences of putting so much power over medical decisions into the hands of Washington. But I asked a question on Saturday that I think deserves a serious answer. “Is it lunatic to want health care for everybody?” My answer? “I don’t think so.” For goodness’ sake, WHO doesn’t want Americans to be able to afford medical care? WHO wants to see a family bankrupted because somebody develops cancer? WHO enjoys watching insurance companies make decisions that can determine whether someone receives treatment? I certainly don’t. And I suspect most conservatives feel exactly the same way.
Our disagreement isn’t necessarily about the desired OUTCOME. It’s about HOW we get there, WHAT it costs, WHO pays for it and whether the proposed solution creates MORE PROBLEMS than it solves. That’s not a minor distinction. It’s the entire argument. When somebody tells me we should have free health care for everybody, my first question is simple. Free? FREE TO WHOM? The doctor isn’t working for free. The nurses aren’t working for free. The hospital certainly isn’t operating for free, and I have yet to encounter a pharmaceutical company that accepts warm feelings as payment. Somebody is paying. And when politicians promise that the billionaires will pick up the tab, I want to see the numbers. Not a slogan. Not a speech about fairness.
Actual numbers showing WHAT the program would cost, HOW it would be funded and WHAT happens when the money runs short. Those are reasonable questions. They’re the questions responsible adults are supposed to ask BEFORE committing the American people to enormous government programs. And if the answers don’t add up, we’re entitled to say so. But calling everybody who wants affordable health care a lunatic doesn’t get us any closer to solving the problem. In fact, it lets conservatives avoid a question I’ve been asking Republicans for years. What’s your alternative? I’ve said repeatedly that Republicans have spent far too much time explaining why Obamacare is terrible and nowhere near enough time offering Americans a convincing plan of their own. If we’re so certain that our approach would work better, why aren’t we better at explaining it?
The same thing applies to CHILD CARE. Progressives want universal child care. I understand why the idea appeals to people. Raising children is expensive, and working parents often struggle with the cost of finding someone trustworthy to look after their children. But I also believe parents have responsibilities that cannot simply be transferred to the federal government. Our parents made SACRIFICES. They adjusted their lives, their finances and their expectations to provide for their families. That’s part of what parenthood means. So when someone proposes that taxpayers should assume a much larger Responsibility for child care, I want to know WHERE the money comes from and WHAT role families will retain. That doesn’t mean I believe parents struggling with child care costs are asking an unreasonable question. It means I disagree with the proposed answer.
And there’s another issue we discussed Saturday that illustrates how profound these disagreements can become: CITIZENSHIP. I believe American citizenship means something. I believe people who come to this country legally, follow our laws and wait their turn should not be disadvantaged by policies that reward people who entered illegally. Progressives have a different view of how government benefits and immigration status should interact. That disagreement isn’t imaginary. It affects public spending, immigration policy and the obligations citizens have to one another. And it’s worth fighting about politically.
But we don’t have to pretend every person who sees it differently has lost his mind. You know what happens when you start believing everybody on the other side is crazy? You stop listening. And once you stop listening, you stop learning why people believe what they believe. That makes it considerably harder to change their minds. I spent a long time working with Rush. Nobody could dismantle a liberal argument quite the way he could, and he certainly knew how to have fun doing it. But the great thing about Rush wasn’t simply that he could make people laugh. It was that he could explain what was wrong with an idea in language people understood. He challenged assumptions. He exposed contradictions. He made the argument. And that’s what I want conservatives to remember.
We don’t need to concede our principles to understand another person’s concerns. We don’t NEED to embrace socialism to recognize that people are worried about medical bills. We don’t NEED to support government-funded child care for everyone to understand why working parents are having a difficult time. And we certainly don’t NEED to call every Democrat a lunatic to demonstrate that we disagree with Democratic policies. I’ve had Democrats call my program for years. Some are regular listeners whom I’ve come to know and genuinely like. We argue, we laugh, and sometimes one of them makes a point I have to acknowledge.
IMAGINE THAT. A conservative admitting that a Democrat occasionally says something worth considering. Don’t tell Washington. They might revoke my membership card. But I am not interested in winning some IMAGINARY CONTEST over who can deliver the nastiest insult. I’m interested in getting things right. And if a political opponent proposes something that would cost taxpayers a fortune, expand government beyond its proper role or undermine principles I believe are essential to this country, I intend to challenge it. Vigorously.
I just don’t need to declare that person mentally defective before explaining why. That’s too easy. And frankly, if our conservative arguments are as strong as I believe they are, we shouldn’t need to.
Dear FRiends,
We need your continuing support to keep FR funded. Your donations are our sole source of funding. No sugar daddies, no advertisers, no paid memberships, no commercial sales, no gimmicks, no tax subsidies. No spam, no pop-ups, no ad trackers.
If you enjoy using FR and agree it's a worthwhile endeavor, please consider making a contribution today:
Click here: to donate by Credit Card
Or here: to donate by PayPal
Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794
Thank you very much and God bless you,
Jim
Mega MAGA Dittos!
“Progressives want universal child care.”
There really no need for such a thing.
My sister worked for a cheapskate employer that provided pre-school care for the rich of Albany, NY, but that was the only instance of pre-kindergarten childcare that I remember from my youth.
My mom stayed home, as most other moms on the street did. Only Mrs. Fitzgerald worked a regular job as a secretary for a large company. I think her eldest son Mark watched over her younger kids. I have no idea who watched over Mark when he was young.
Not every Democrat is a horse thief.
As for childcare, mom A might work 3 days one week and 4 days the following week, mom B might work 4 days one week and 3 days the following week.
The two moms would switch childminding.
If the moms work 10 hours a day, they’d average 35 hours a week.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.