Just for the record, that isn’t the author. I am. Never knew about this forum until someone passed this post along so I figured I would create an account just to clear his name so he didn’t get blamed for such a terrible article :)
What are the scenarios you envision for such a discussion? Since any event that would cause the United States to melt down into anarchy would immediately cause China to "intervene", are you envisioning a "Red Dawn" sort of scenario?
I am pretty firmly on the side of people who consider this a childish fantasy. If our governmental system melted down, there far too many powerful state actors who would sweep into the vacuum.
Obviously too, I disagreed with your dismissal of the 7.62mm NATO: it's common, available, penetrates cover effectively (brick walls, heavy brush, sandbags, vehicles - even concrete gravestones) and is as accurate as the platform you fire it from. During my youth, I broke the range record at Puuloa Rifle Range by firing 34 consecutive V-ring (5 inch circle) bullseyes at 600m with match M-14, iron sights. I'm pretty sure the record stands today.
I carried the M-14 for 17 months in combat and refused the M-16 when those things showed up - luckily for me.
I think we both run on with words, don't we?
Welcome to FreeRepublic, FRiend.
And for the record, your article is endorsed by Travis McGee. With that, no one elses two cents matters.