Posted on 08/02/2018 4:41:57 AM PDT by Travis McGee
Back during the protracted recount following the 2000 Bush-Gore election, I offered a subversive bit of advice in a VDARE article entitled: GOP Future Depends on Winning Larger Share of the White Vote.
Bushs boy-genius strategist Karl Rove had achieved acclaim by declaring that the only hope for the Republican Party to cope with changing demographics was in enticing Hispanic voters by encouraging even more immigration. Sure, the GOP would lose on each immigrant vote cast, but would make up for it on volume. Or something.
Yet I pointed out that Bush could have won in an Electoral College landslide merely by upping his share of the white vote from 54 percent to 57 percent.
I further noted that the most obvious source of additional white votes were white union familiesReagan Democratsin states Bush had lost narrowly, such as Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania. And one way to appeal to blue-collar whites in the crucial north-central swing states was to be more skeptical of immigration.
Although this turned out to be more or less the winning strategy for Donald Trump sixteen years later, my article was immediately banned from discussion at the mainstream GOP website Free Republic as divisive and promoting racism. Although a vote cast by a white was still counted, technically speaking, as equal to a vote cast by a nonwhite, as far back as 2000 it was considered by Establishment Republicans to be morally repulsive to appeal to the self-interest of those most likely to swing Republican. What would the Democrats say?
(The rest at the Takimag link.)
http://takimag.com/article/a_half_century_of_amnesia_steve_sailer/print#ixzz5N1JA4QDF
Highly, highly recommended reading, that was recommended to me up-thread:
https://lkyonrace.wordpress.com/
Lee Kuan Yew did not have our white-guilt/fear filters.
I agree. FR totally missed the opportunity to shift the Overton Window regarding open borders vs border protection.
The border protectors were silenced or run off of FR by the open-border GOPe crowd for some critical years in the early 2000s.
And most of the border is STILL wide open.
5....4....3.....2....1....... and it’s gone.....
It’s been up a day and it’s still here....
My original screen name was banned in 2005 for participating in anti illegal alien posts. Seems at the time Jim was very much pro illegal alien.
FR is far from lockstep, or mainstream, GOP discussions.
In general, we’re just pro-American.
And thanks for all you do, Matt. You are an encouragement to a whole lot of us. Keep it up.
Indeed
A hero to my spawn (s)
I can see how from Sailer’s perspective (Vdare permabanned) it’s mainstream. But there is no doubt FR missed a golden opportunity to move the debate on border protection in the early 2000s. The open-border GOPe (cheap labor uber alles!) crowd held far too much sway here at that time. FR was, and is, conservative on most subjects, but in the early 2000s, it was way off the mark on border protection.
I remember it was not allowed to even post articles on the Minutemen! That was a bannable offence! Patriotic Americans who wanted to help the USBP to guard our borders were considered something nasty, near to neo-Nazis here on FR.
Yep, FR missed a golden opportunity to shift the debate back when it would have really mattered. And our border is still wide open.
Far too many Americans desire illegal aliens. Now, 20% of Mexico’s citizens live here, mostly illegally.
Painfully we still have a few holdouts here who see the world though 1980s lenses over immigration and national complexion
FR was for sure mainstream GOP then
The party had big wampum here
People were so lemming like and not very courageous to risk being called racist
The worm has turned though
“Yep, FR missed a golden opportunity to shift the debate back when it would have really mattered.”
The anger that coalesced the support that drove Trump to win could have been generated back in the 2004-2007 timeframe and kept Obama out. It was happening, but so many, FR included, demanded we shut up about illegal aliens, so the fever died out. The eGOP open border, cheap labor, lobby hit FR hard back then. The Minutemen were stomped out of existence. FR helped do that. I know the eGOP FReepers were very much involve din that. They still are. I stopped donating after that. Let the eGOP fund FR.
As you said, it could have mattered, but it was squelched instead.
It wasnt just illegal immigration that got people banned. It was the adamant opposition to the GOPe in the primaries. After the BS Mcain run many were purged in Commie Mittens run also. Myself included. Seemed like FR mafia of the Obama era were too mainstream IMHO.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.