Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

To: bcsco
Better yet, tell that to the Hugh Glass', Joseph Walkers, 'Broken Hand' Tom Fitzpatricks, Jedediah Smiths,..........Doggone, tell it to Lewis & Clark, or President Thomas Jefferson, who sent their expedition. In their era what they did was considered stupid and hazardous. With your logic we'd all be better off had they not heeded their call. What they did was ridiculous.

More nonsense. Lewis and Clark were doing a necessary job for the nation. The mountain men were out there to make money by trapping beaver, and they neither expected nor received any help from government.

OTOH, the lost climbers were playing a dangerous game for the sport involved. No one's property would have been injured and the nation would not have lost any benefits if the climbers had not gone up that mountain. That isn't even close to being the same thing as a vital military expedition in the service of the national interest such as Lewis and Clark's Voyage of Discovery.

353 posted on 12/17/2006 4:18:08 PM PST by epow (Christ the Lord is born today, Hallelulyah! . I celebrate my Savior's birth, not a generic holiday)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 346 | View Replies ]


To: epow
Lewis and Clark were doing a necessary job for the nation.

In hindsight, yes. But at the time it was considered 'nonsense' by many. The Louisiana Purchased was highly contested. So was the funding for, and whole idea of, the expedition. It became popular only after they returned (belatedly and after much concern back in Washington) with only one fatality.

If you believe the Mountain Men traveled West solely for monetary reasons then you don't know your history. There were more lucrative and less demanding jobs in the States. And if it weren't for them, England and France could possibly have claimed large portions of the territory. No, there was far more at play with them than self-interest.

Now there is one confirmed dead among the climbers. I suppose by some logic on this forum we should be celebrating the cleansing of the gene pool once again. Well, have at it. But pardon me if I don't attend the party.

359 posted on 12/17/2006 4:54:13 PM PST by bcsco ("He who is wedded to the spirit of the age is soon a widower" ? Anonymous)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 353 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson