[Congressman Billybob]

Ellis Henican is a chronic liar and Democrat shill. Whatever defects Gulliani may have, don't count on anything by Henican to describe them accurately. As for the book, I don;t know if it, also, is a hit piece rather than informative.

Congressman Billybob

Latest article: "Bad Judges Make Bad Law."

Please see my most recent new statement on running for Congress, here.

[Eagle Forgotten]

Henican definitely leans left but has a certain amount of cynicism toward all politicians.

As for the book, one of the co-authors, Wayne Barrett, has been an ardent Giuliani foe for years. Your concern that the book is a hit piece is certainly a reasonable one, but that's why I mentioned that the book seems to address managerial competence rather than ideology. I mean, there's no dispute that the radios didn't work. That's the kind of thing that isn't a liberal-versus-conservative issue.

[arthurus]

I award zero credence to anything that comes from the Village Voice but that private life will severely limit Giuiliani's possibilities in the Bible Belt which has been the Republicans' main reservoir. Can we gain enough from the homosexual vote and from illegals to make up for it?

[mewzilla]

Ellis Henican is a chronic liar and Democrat shill.

I see the Clintons' hands in this.

[DustyMoment]

Ellis Henican is a chronic liar and Democrat shill. Whatever defects Gulliani may have, don't count on anything by Henican to describe them accurately. As for the book, I don;t know if it, also, is a hit piece rather than informative.

Exactly what I was thinking, although I do believe there might be more of a "hit piece" feeling associated with it.