Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Did dinosaur fossils inspire the mythical griffin? Did mammoth bones shape the story of the Gigantomachy? Were the cyclopes modeled on the skulls of dwarf elephants? This video investigates some of the fascinating intersections between fossils and the Greek myths. This video is part of a collaboration with ‪@NORTH02 --‬ Check out their video "Scimitar Cats, Cave Bears, and Behemoths" for more on the fossils that so fascinated the ancient Greeks and Romans.
Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and the Greek Myths | 8:55
toldinstone | 522K subscribers | 179,486 views | August 20, 2021
Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and the Greek Myths | 8:55 | toldinstone | 522K subscribers | 179,486 views | August 20, 2021
Transcript
·Introduction
0:01·in 58 bc
0:03·marcus emilius scouris an ambitious
0:06·roman politician
0:07·sponsored spectacular games
0:10·a zoo was set up in the circus complete
0:13·with an artificial lake for crocodiles
0:15·and hippos
0:17·a wooden theater rose nearby gleaming
0:19·with imported marble columns
0:22·and on the campus marshes alongside many
0:25·other marvels from distant lands the
0:27·skeleton of a monster was displayed
0:31·the monster's bones were colossal
0:34·the ribs were taller than the mightiest
0:36·elephant
0:37·the spine was a foot and a half thick
0:39·and no less than 40 feet 12 meters long
0:44·these it was proclaimed were the remains
0:46·of the beast sent to devour princess
0:49·andromeda slain by the hero perseus
0:53·we don't know what the bones actually
0:55·were
0:56·they may have belonged to a beached
0:58·sperm whale
1:00·or they may have been fossils discovered
1:02·by chance and associated with the only
1:05·stories that seemed to explain them the
1:07·greek myths
1:10·this video is a collaboration with
1:12·north02
1:14·a channel dedicated to paleontology and
1:16·anthropology
1:18·northzero2's video linked in the
1:20·description explores the prehistoric
1:22·animals whose fossils so fascinated the
1:25·greeks and romans
1:27·my video investigates how those fossils
1:29·impacted the greek myths
1:32·so without any further ado let's launch
1:34·into our first myth
·Dinosaurs and Griffins
1:37·beyond the roving scythians
1:39·by the roots of the deadly mountains
1:41·that guarded the passes to india
1:43·griffins prowled
1:45·they were massive creatures with lions
1:47·bodies and the wings and beaks of eagles
1:51·when they weren't hunting in the
1:53·wilderness around their windswept home
1:55·they were burrowing with their powerful
1:56·claws seeking gold for their nests
2:00·near the griffins lived the aramaspians
2:03·a tribe of men born with only one eye
2:06·despite rather limited depth perception
2:09·the aramaspians had no trouble seeing
2:11·the value of the gold heaped around the
2:13·griffin's nests
2:15·on moonless nights they rode into the
2:18·deserts where the griffins lived and
2:20·quietly plundered the nests
2:22·if the griffins woke they attacked the
2:24·men killing anyone they could catch
2:28·according to classical folklorist
2:30·Adrienne Mayor the Greek stories about
2:32·griffins originated in the foothills of
2:34·the altay and tianshan mountains where
2:37·mesozoic fossils erode from slopes of
2:40·red stone
2:42·one of the more common fossils in this
2:44·region is the protoceratops
2:46·a small dinosaur with a festive crest on
2:49·its head
2:50·protoceratops fossils are sometimes
2:53·found almost complete occasionally near
2:55·nests of fossilized eggs
2:59·here mayer argues are all the
3:01·ingredients of the griffin myth nomadic
3:04·miners and traders seeing the bones and
3:07·eggs understood them as the remains of
3:09·winged beasts guarding their nests
3:12·associated those remains with stray
3:13·deposits of alluvial gold and created a
3:16·tradition that was eventually
3:18·communicated to the greek world
3:21·so were protoceratops fossils really
3:24·responsible for the griffins
3:26·possibly but we should be wary of
3:29·assuming a direct causal relationship
3:32·griffin-like composite creatures had a
3:34·long history in greek art and appeared
3:36·centuries before any conceivable contact
3:38·with central asia
3:40·the greek conception of the griffin may
3:42·have been influenced more or less
3:44·indirectly by central asian fossils but
3:47·there's no way to conclusively prove a
3:49·connection
3:51·in the depths of mythic time the gods
·Mammoths and Giants
3:54·confronted a terrible threat
3:56·huge and terrifying creatures
3:58·snake-footed with the primordial
4:00·strength of their mother earth
4:02·the giants
4:04·armed with boulders and tree trunks the
4:06·giants climbed the slopes of olympus and
4:09·attacked the palaces of the gods
4:11·every god was involved in the ensuing
4:13·battle
4:15·dionysus swatted giants with his iv'd
4:17·staff
4:18·hephaestus hurled missiles of liquid
4:20·metal
4:22·zeus struck down the mightiest giant
4:24·with a thunderbolt
4:26·at last after a titanic struggle the
4:28·giants were hurled down to earth where
4:30·hercules finished off the survivors
4:34·the ancient greeks saw evidence of the
4:36·giants fall all around them
4:39·many parts of greece have rich fossil
4:41·deposits from the miocene to pleistocene
4:44·epics
4:45·when mammoths mastodons and other
4:48·oversized critters wandered the
4:50·landscape
4:52·the fossils left by these animals were
4:54·enormous the biggest mammoths stood up
4:57·to fifteen feet or four and a half
4:59·meters at the shoulder
5:02·since the best preserved bones from
5:04·these skeletons are often human-looking
5:06·femurs and scapulae and since the greeks
5:09·who had not yet encountered elephants
5:11·knew of no living animals so huge
5:14·large fossils were frequently
5:16·interpreted as the remains of fallen
5:18·giants
5:20·the greeks associated several places
5:22·with the battle of the gods and giants
5:24·but thought the giant's last stand had
5:26·occurred near megalopolis in the central
5:28·peloponnese where masses of prehistoric
5:31·bones were embedded in deposits of
5:33·ligonite coal
5:35·the coal beds were combustible and sent
5:37·up clouds of smoke when kindled by
5:39·summer lightning
5:41·this it was thought was the terrible
5:43·fire of zeus's thunderbolts still
5:45·smoldering after many centuries
5:49·as in the case of the griffins we
5:50·shouldn't assume that the megalopolous
5:53·fossils were responsible for the myth of
5:55·the giants fall
5:57·the myth almost certainly came first and
5:59·shaped the interpretation of the huge
6:01·bones
6:02·but if nothing else the megalopolis
6:05·fossils gave dramatic physical shape to
6:08·the giants and their battle with the
6:09·gods in the greek imagination
6:12·and now our final and most famous
·Dwarf Elephants and Cyclopes
6:15·example
6:16·there were a few different groups of
6:18·cyclopes in greek myth but the most
6:21·notorious were the tribe of gigantic
6:23·man-eating and generally unpleasant
6:26·one-eyed shepherds who lived in caves on
6:28·the coast of sicily
6:30·in 1914 the austrian paleontologist
6:33·ortheniel abel suggested that the
6:36·cyclops myth was inspired by dwarf
6:38·elephant fossils
6:40·these remains belonged to populations
6:43·stranded on sicily and other islands by
6:45·the rising sea levels of ice age
6:47·interglacial periods
6:49·since smaller animals were better
6:51·adapted to the scarcer resources of an
6:53·island the ancient elephants of sicily
6:56·gradually became much more compact than
6:58·their mainland cousins eventually
7:00·shrinking to the size of ponies
7:03·the bones of dwarf elephants looked
7:05·unlike those of any other animal
7:07·familiar to the early greeks
7:10·their skulls about twice human size were
7:13·especially uncanny with a huge nasal
7:15·cavity in the center of the forehead
7:18·on a living elephant this is the base of
7:20·the trunk
7:21·but to someone who has never seen an
7:23·elephant it looks more than a little
7:25·like a gigantic eye socket
7:28·it would have been easy for an ancient
7:30·observer to mistake the fossilized head
7:32·of a dwarf elephant for the skull of a
7:34·monstrous one-eyed man
7:37·especially when jumbled and half-buried
7:39·the rest of the elephant's bones could
7:41·be interpreted in the same light
7:43·and since the fossils were often found
7:45·in seaside caves it would have been
7:47·natural to infer that the one-eyed
7:49·giants to which the bones belonged had
7:51·been cave dwellers
7:53·the theory that dwarf elephant skulls
7:55·were responsible for the greek cyclops
7:57·is appealing
7:59·it is however just a theory
8:02·in this case as always we cannot assume
8:05·a direct relationship between fossil and
8:07·myth
8:09·we can only point to the possibility of
8:10·a connection and remember that myths are
8:13·seldom straightforward things
·Conclusion
8:16·for much more on the fossils of the
8:18·ancient mediterranean check out the
8:19·video by north02 which is linked in the
8:22·description
8:24·if you're new to my channel you might
8:25·also be interested in my book naked
8:28·statues fat gladiators and war elephants
8:31·which provides more detail about the
8:32·interpretation of fossils and many other
8:34·aspects of greek myth and popular belief
8:38·thanks for watching

2 posted on 11/05/2024 8:39:14 PM PST by SunkenCiv (Dear leftists, that victory was just the undercard.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies ]


toldinstone Cleaned-up Transcript!

Introduction

In 58 BC, Marcus Emilius Scaurus, an ambitious Roman politician, sponsored spectacular games. A zoo was set up in the circus, complete with an artificial lake for crocodiles and hippos. A wooden theater rose nearby, gleaming with imported marble columns, and on the campus marshes, alongside many other marvels from distant lands, the skeleton of a monster was displayed.

The monster’s bones were colossal; the ribs were taller than the mightiest elephant. The spine was a foot and a half thick and no less than 40 feet (12 meters) long. These, it was proclaimed, were the remains of the beast sent to devour Princess Andromeda, slain by the hero Perseus. We don’t know what the bones actually were; they may have belonged to a beached sperm whale, or they may have been fossils discovered by chance and associated with the only stories that seemed to explain them: the Greek myths.

This video is a collaboration with North02, a channel dedicated to paleontology and anthropology. North02’s video, linked in the description, explores the prehistoric animals whose fossils so fascinated the Greeks and Romans. My video investigates how those fossils impacted the Greek myths. So, without any further ado, let’s launch into our first myth.

Dinosaurs and Griffins

Beyond the roving Scythians, by the roots of the deadly mountains that guarded the passes to India, griffins prowled. They were massive creatures with lion’s bodies and the wings and beaks of eagles. When they weren’t hunting in the wilderness around their windswept home, they were burrowing with their powerful claws, seeking gold for their nests. Near the griffins lived the Aramaspians, a tribe of men born with only one eye. Despite rather limited depth perception, the Aramaspians had no trouble seeing the value of the gold heaped around the griffin’s nests. On moonless nights, they rode into the deserts where the griffins lived and quietly plundered the nests. If the griffins woke, they attacked the men, killing anyone they could catch.

According to classical folklorist Adrienne Mayer, the Greek stories about griffins originated in the foothills of the Altay and Tianshan mountains, where Mesozoic fossils erode from slopes of red stone. One of the more common fossils in this region is the Protoceratops, a small dinosaur with a festive crest on its head. Protoceratops fossils are sometimes found almost complete, occasionally near nests of fossilized eggs. Here, Mayer argues, are all the ingredients of the griffin myth: nomadic miners and traders, seeing the bones and eggs, understood them as the remains of winged beasts guarding their nests, associated those remains with stray deposits of alluvial gold, and created a tradition that was eventually communicated to the Greek world.

So, were Protoceratops fossils really responsible for the griffins? Possibly, but we should be wary of assuming a direct causal relationship. Griffin-like composite creatures had a long history in Greek art and appeared centuries before any conceivable contact with Central Asia. The Greek conception of the griffin may have been influenced more or less indirectly by Central Asian fossils, but there’s no way to conclusively prove a connection.

Mammoths and Giants

In the depths of mythic time, the gods confronted a terrible threat: huge and terrifying creatures, snake-footed, with the primordial strength of their mother Earth—the giants. Armed with boulders and tree trunks, the giants climbed the slopes of Olympus and attacked the palaces of the gods. Every god was involved in the ensuing battle. Dionysus swatted giants with his ivy’d staff; Hephaestus hurled missiles of liquid metal; Zeus struck down the mightiest giant with a thunderbolt. At last, after a titanic struggle, the giants were hurled down to Earth, where Hercules finished off the survivors.

The ancient Greeks saw evidence of the giants’ fall all around them. Many parts of Greece have rich fossil deposits from the Miocene to Pleistocene epochs, when mammoths, mastodons, and other oversized critters wandered the landscape. The fossils left by these animals were enormous; the biggest mammoths stood up to fifteen feet (four and a half meters) at the shoulder. Since the best-preserved bones from these skeletons are often human-looking femurs and scapulae, and since the Greeks, who had not yet encountered elephants, knew of no living animals so huge, large fossils were frequently interpreted as the remains of fallen giants.

The Greeks associated several places with the battle of the gods and giants but thought the giants’ last stand had occurred near Megalopolis in the central Peloponnese, where masses of prehistoric bones were embedded in deposits of lignite coal. The coal beds were combustible and sent up clouds of smoke when kindled by summer lightning. This, it was thought, was the terrible fire of Zeus’s thunderbolts, still smoldering after many centuries. As in the case of the griffins, we shouldn’t assume that the Megalopolis fossils were responsible for the myth of the giants’ fall. The myth almost certainly came first and shaped the interpretation of the huge bones. But if nothing else, the Megalopolis fossils gave dramatic physical shape to the giants and their battle with the gods in the Greek imagination.

Dwarf Elephants and Cyclopes

And now our final and most famous example: there were a few different groups of Cyclopes in Greek myth, but the most notorious were the tribe of gigantic, man-eating, and generally unpleasant one-eyed shepherds who lived in caves on the coast of Sicily. In 1914, the Austrian paleontologist Ortheniel Abel suggested that the Cyclops myth was inspired by dwarf elephant fossils. These remains belonged to populations stranded on Sicily and other islands by the rising sea levels of ice age interglacial periods. Since smaller animals were better adapted to the scarcer resources of an island, the ancient elephants of Sicily gradually became much more compact than their mainland cousins, eventually shrinking to the size of ponies.

The bones of dwarf elephants looked unlike those of any other animal familiar to the early Greeks. Their skulls, about twice human size, were especially uncanny, with a huge nasal cavity in the center of the forehead. On a living elephant, this is the base of the trunk, but to someone who has never seen an elephant, it looks more than a little like a gigantic eye socket. It would have been easy for an ancient observer to mistake the fossilized head of a dwarf elephant for the skull of a monstrous one-eyed man, especially when jumbled and half-buried. The rest of the elephant’s bones could be interpreted in the same light, and since the fossils were often found in seaside caves, it would have been natural to infer that the one-eyed giants to which the bones belonged had been cave dwellers.

The theory that dwarf elephant skulls were responsible for the Greek Cyclops is appealing; it is, however, just a theory. In this case, as always, we cannot assume a direct relationship between fossil and myth. We can only point to the possibility of a connection and remember that myths are seldom straightforward things.

Conclusion

For much more on the fossils of the ancient Mediterranean, check out the video by North02, which is linked in the description. If you’re new to my channel, you might also be interested in my book, Naked Statues, Fat Gladiators, and War Elephants, which provides more detail about the interpretation of fossils and many other aspects of Greek myth and popular belief. Thanks for watching.


10 posted on 10/01/2026 5:23:27 AM PDT by SunkenCiv (TDS -- it's not just for DNC shills and jihadists anymore -- oh, wait, yeah it is.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson