But, I read "The Hobbit" and "LOTR" at least once a year [usually during the summer -- in my "retirement hammock"...] '-)
So -- I agree that the bottom graphic appropriately reflects Tolkien's consistent excellence.
And, if the upper graphic accurately represents inconsistency in "GOT", I'd say it is probably the cleverest and most concise critique I've ever seen.
ThanQ for posting that!
TXnMA