Hah! I think I'm in the same boat. For what it's worth I am a lifelong Eagles fan and from watching him here I am well acquainted with Andy Reid's ability to lose when he shouldn't, to collapse after a promising start, and to blow games because he screws up the clock really badly. He's won a lot of games but has two big flaws: he tends to lose to teams he should beat AND he wilts a bit when the plan isn't playing out as expected (which tends to happen deep in the playoffs, explaining how he kept getting getting knocked out in the NFC championship game year after year after year).
He'll turn it around just enough to miss the playoffs by one game, just enough that Chef's fans think he's still got it. That's how he rolls in off years.