Overall, Reagan was better than all others since JFK. Only 2 issues I have with Reagan...(1) he did not veto enough of the spending bills, causing federal spending to almost triple during his 8 years and (2) he allowed too many imports from China, instead of insisting on a more balanced trade.
I realize Reagan had to deal with majority democrat congress, but if he used the veto more often, we can say he at least tried.
The amnesty issue was a bad decision by Reagan. Maybe you can add that as #3 on your list.