[CatherineofAragon]

"I don’t buy it, either. On WD, there are many little details like that that come back to mean something later."

Yes. And if a Freeper caught it (and that was a GREAT catch), no doubt plenty of TWD crew would have, too.

"But I can’t see Carl not being aware and ready."

I agree. But what if they were both asleep?

[Thorliveshere]

I think if Pete had killed someone, it would have been noted, as it showed Michonne later on putting her sword back on rather than hang it, so I would THINK in that time another death would have been noted.

[laplata]

“But I can’t see Carl not being aware and ready.”

I agree. But what if they were both asleep?

---

That makes me nervous. LOL