[retrokitten]

I didn’t care for Carly last night or tonight. She was shouty and screechy. I was in the minority on the board.

[Miss Didi]

I was with you, Kittie. ;) I never liked her.

[purpleraine]

LOL! You must have carpal tunnel from your speed dial.

[conservativebabe]

I totally agree with you. I said that while watching. It sounded like she was yelling at times.

[Sir_Ed]

I thought Carly was horrible.

It seemed like she was screeching out, angrily, “Do you think You’re Who they say you are?”

I didn’t see her as joyful and bright, at all...I saw her as angry, and screeching, as she has been from the start.

Ed

[peggybac]

I love Carly’s voice but it sounded like she was trying to yell to be heard over the backup singers last night (and tonight). They were way too loud.

[Wolfstar]

I didn’t care for Carly last night or tonight. She was shouty and screechy. I was in the minority on the board.

You're right, RK. Carly wasn't as bad as Jason and Brooke, but she was pretty awful in her own right. Twice she completely got off the timing, beat and melody of the song. The backup singers were on melody and timing, and Carly was off in her own world. That's when she sounded most screechy.

[Netizen]

I didn’t like Carly last night either. I didn’t like the way they did the song. I agree with the person that commented on ‘the song’.

[fkabuckeyesrule]

I watched this show for the first time last night. I can’t belive the first girl (from tuesday)was in the bottom two. Kinda reminds me of why I have not been watching.