I don't think I've ever the Dixie Chicks do a song, but I've heard original versions of some of their songs. I tend to shy away from Nashville hit-machine/image conscious type artists.
Thats what the ywant you to beleive, but in reality they had a small army putting this album together. Their writing credits most likely come from real talented artists allowing them to sit in on the creative session.
I haven't listened to their new songs, save "Not Ready To Make Nice". I'd venture to guess that they probably are pretty good, with all the talent they had working on the album, plus the Chicks' natural harmony and blend of mandolin/fiddle. Rick Rubin produced the record, and he is very successful at putting them together.
I just can't listen to them without thinking how mean-spirited they are and how hard they play the victim card. Also, the numbers I posted may be premature - the website I referenced shows that they have 109,000 sales with 45% reported, so it may go up a little.
We'll see later today or tomorrow.