Nope! I think she is great, too!
I think the thing with her is a bit of self-consciousness. The way she comes across reminds me a little bit of me in college . I found out all these girls thought I was a total snob UNTIL they got to know me. It was because of how they perceived me. I had issues with self-esteem, but I ALWAYS tried to put up a self-confident posture. The way she hides behind her clothes makes me think that she may have issues with her body image. Why? I don't know. My guess people have been saying things about her being a "bigger girl" like they did last year to Carrie Underwood. Or maybe she saw herself on camera, and she wasn't comfortable with it. The camera DOES seem to add a little weight to you, depending on the angle. Just trying to stick up a little for Katherine, here. Both my husband and I pick her as one of the top three.
I also think she is beautiful--reminds me of CZ-J. But if I have to go with my FAVORITE? It is Chris! ;^)
Of course, I could be totally WRONG, and she could be a stuck-up brat, but I just don't think so. :^)
The way she (McPhee) hides behind her clothes makes me think that she may have issues with her body image. Why? I don't know.
That's the only explanation that makes sense to me, and I don't know why either. She has an IDEAL body, IMO. But she hides it with baggy blouses.
She has the confidence to sing in front of millions of people, but not the confidence to wear form-fitting clothes ... I don't get it--especially when Mandisa is standing beside her wearing those gigantic blue jeans.