You could say that for all of them.
Elliott--Safe 1st song, Very good vocal on #2
Paris--Sucky first song, very good on #2
Chris--Killed the first, crashed on #2
Kat--Butchered the 1st, good on second
Taylor--Killed the 1st, boring #2
That's true. But IMO, Chris and Taylor's good songs were the best of the bunch.