Rundown: Kevin Roberts of 'Heritage Foundation' on Tucker Carlson-Nick Fuentes Scandal (Oct/27-Nov/8)

Writing the Right ^ | Nov 10, 2025

[Freeleesy]

Kevin Roberts of 'Heritage Foundation' on Tucker Carlson-Nick Fuentes Scandal

Complete Summary – October 27 to November 9, 2025

Overview of the Scandal

The controversy began after Tucker Carlson interviewed white nationalist and Holocaust denier Nick Fuentes on October 27, 2025, in a two-hour podcast that amassed over 17 million views on X. Carlson asked softball questions, nodded approvingly, and did not challenge Fuentes’ antisemitic remarks, praise for Hitler and Stalin, or claims about “organized Jewry” controlling U.S. politics. Carlson also accused pro-Israel American Christians of having a “brain virus” and being heretics.

This triggered bipartisan outrage, with critics accusing Carlson of normalizing neo-Nazi ideology.

Note: The interview was not adversarial. Carlson’s tone and lack of pushback were widely interpreted as tacit endorsement, not mere platforming. This became a central point of criticism across conservative, mainstream, and Jewish media.

Kevin Roberts’ Initial Defense (Oct 30–31, 2025)

Heritage Foundation President Kevin Roberts released a video on October 30 defending Carlson as a “close friend” of Heritage and opposing efforts to “cancel” him or Fuentes.

“Christians can critique the state of Israel without being anti-Semitic. Conservatives should feel no obligation to reflexively support any foreign government… I disagree with, and even abhor, things that Nick Fuentes says, but canceling him is not the answer either. When we disagree… we challenge those ideas in debate.”

— Kevin Roberts, Heritage Foundation President

• Framed criticism as a “venomous coalition” imposing loyalty to Israel.
• Emphasized free speech, American interests first, and rejected “cancel culture.”
• Called the backlash divisive and aimed at sowing division among conservatives.

Trending on X (Oct 31): Statement drew sharp rebukes from Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, Senator Ted Cruz, and pro-Israel advocates, who accused Heritage of mainstreaming hate.

Note: Roberts later admitted in a leaked staff meeting (Nov 5) that he “didn’t know much about this Fuentes guy” — a revelation that fueled internal outrage, given Fuentes’ long public record of Holocaust denial and Hitler praise.

Immediate Backlash & Media Coverage

Wall Street Journal Editorial (Nov 2)

“The New Right’s New Antisemites”

• Called antisemitism a “growing old political poison” on the new right, led by podcasters.
• Accused Roberts of “floundering in the Tucker Carlson-Nick Fuentes fever swamps” and being an “apologist.”
• Criticized framing the issue as Christian freedom vs. Israel loyalty, not antisemitism.
• Mocked “cancel culture” claims:
  “Mr. Fuentes has free speech… Is it now ‘cancel culture’ to criticize Mr. Carlson for treating Mr. Fuentes like a political truth-teller?”
• Quoted Ted Cruz: “If you say nothing when someone tells you that Adolf Hitler was cool, you are a coward and complicit in evil.”

Mediaite (Nov 3)

Summarized WSJ’s “scathing op-ed,” highlighting Roberts’ initial Jew-baiting and scramble to list Fuentes’ “odiousness” amid criticism.

NY Post Op-Ed by Rich Lowry (Nov 3)

Accused Carlson of “poison[ing] us with hatred”, but noted Trump as a barrier.

FrontPage Mag by Jamie Glazov (Oct 30)

• Called Carlson’s Israel claims “vicious and grotesque lie[s].”
• Defended IDF’s efforts to spare Palestinian lives; accused Carlson of ignoring:
  • Palestinian indoctrination to hate/kill Jews
  • Hamas human shields
  • Christian persecution under Islam
  • Biblical ties to Israel/Judaism (e.g., Jesus in the Temple, Passover Seder)
• Questioned Carlson’s Christian credentials and motives.

CNN NewsNight with Abby Phillip (Oct 31)

Panel discussed MAGA divide. Key points:

• Phillip: “Shocked” Heritage defended not canceling Fuentes.
• Criticized Tucker’s nodding/implicit endorsement.
• J.D. Vance at Turning Point: Granted premise that Israel “controls” U.S. presidents (said Trump isn’t).
• Eric Erickson: Roberts/Vance courting young Zoomers via tolerance for inflammatory positions.
• Warned of hypocrisy in condemning left-wing antisemitism but not right-wing.
• Potential for Fuentes to fill void post-Charlie Kirk’s murder.

Note: Panelists compared the GOP’s tolerance of right-wing antisemitism to selective outrage — condemning campus leftists but defending Fuentes as “debate.”

Internal Heritage Revolt and Resignations

• Mark Goldfeder (Nov 2): Leader of Heritage’s National Task Force to Combat Antisemitism resigned:
  “I cannot serve under someone who thinks Nazis are worth debating.”
• Ryan Neuhaus (Nov 3): Roberts’ chief of staff reassigned to “housing issues” (“Siberia”), then resigned.
• David Bernstein (Nov 3): Former Project Esther member resigned; criticized “venomous coalition” as attack on Jewish agency.
• Laurie Cardoza-Moore (Nov 5): Evangelical Zionist resigned unless Heritage cuts ties with antisemites. Called Carlson a “dangerous antisemite” threatening Jews worldwide.
• Stephen Moore (Nov 7): Ex-Trump adviser left amid controversy.

Leaked Internal Chats (NY Post, Nov 3):

• Staff called Roberts’ defense “ridiculous,” “embarrassing,” “disgusting.”
• One: “Most embarrassed I’ve ever been to be a Heritage employee. It’s not close.”
• Criticized hypocrisy: Roberts canceled Boston College Republicans but defended Fuentes.
• Some interns reportedly agreed with Fuentes.
• Donor hemorrhage: Evangelical and Jewish contributors fled.
• Heritage scrubbed Tucker Carlson Network sponsorship from donations page.

Note: Princeton professor and Heritage board member Robert P. George publicly condemned white supremacy in conservatism and reportedly tried (but failed) to oust Roberts.

Kevin Roberts’ Clarifications and Apologies

• Oct 31: Second statement opposed Fuentes’ “vicious antisemitic ideology.”
• Nov 5 (Leaked Staff Meeting): Admitted:
  “I didn’t know much about this Fuentes guy… underscores the mistake… I made them worse.”
• Nov 5 (Third Video): “Everyone has the responsibility to speak up against antisemitism, even when my friend Tucker Carlson needs challenging.”
• Assured no staff repercussions for dissent.

Broader GOP and Conservative Reactions

• GOP Figures: McConnell, Cruz, Randy Fine (“Carlson has gone ‘insane’ and is ‘dangerous’”), David French, Eric Erickson, Laura Loomer.
• Republican Jewish Coalition Summit: Ted Cruz: “More antisemitism on the right than in my entire life… existential crisis.”
• Ben Shapiro on CNN (Nov 6): Praised apology but called Carlson a “conspiracist laundering antisemitism.”
• Bill Maher (Nov 8): Carlson evolved from “bowtie Republican” to “world’s oldest groyp[er]” platforming Holocaust deniers. Rep. Jared Moskowitz: GOP antisemitism like asking Jews to choose “Germany or Egypt.”

Political Fallout and Electoral Links

• Israel Hayom (Nov 5): Blamed GOP election losses (e.g., Zohran Mamdani as NYC mayor) on distraction with conspiracies over economy/security. Trump failed to unify party.
• Blog Post: Carlson’s “populist poison” pushing young Jews leftward — echoing Charlottesville 2017’s role in Biden’s 2020 campaign.
• USA Today (Nov 6): Heritage made “wrong choice”; Roberts apologized under pressure.

Note: Pew Research (March 2025): 72% of white evangelicals favorable toward Israel; majorities of Muslims (81%), unaffiliated (69%), and Catholics (53%) unfavorable.

References

1. Wall Street Journal Editorial Board – “The New Right’s New Antisemites” – Nov 2, 2025
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/the-new-rights-new-antisemites-d702dcbd

2. Mediaite – “‘Entering Dangerous Territory’: WSJ Drags Nick Fuentes, Tucker Carlson, and Heritage Foundation” – Nov 3, 2025
https://www.mediaite.com/...

3. Rich Lowry, NY Post – “Tucker Carlson aims to poison us with hatred — but Donald Trump stands in the way” – Nov 3, 2025
https://nypost.com/...

4. Jamie Glazov, FrontPage Mag – “Tucker Carlson’s Lies About Israel” – Oct 30, 2025
https://www.frontpagemag.com/...

5. CNN NewsNight Transcript – Aired Oct 31, 2025
https://transcripts.cnn.com/...

6. JFeed – “On Tucker Carlson's Dime. Nick Fuentes Mocks 6 Million Jews…” – Nov 2, 2025
https://www.jfeed.com/...

7. The Wrap – “Heritage Antisemitism Task Force Leader Resigns…” – Nov 2, 2025
https://www.thewrap.com/...

8. NY Times – “G.O.P. Figures Seek Distance From Tucker Carlson…” – Nov 3, 2025
https://www.nytimes.com/...

9. New Republic – “Top Heritage Foundation Staffer Quits Over Nick Fuentes Civil War” – Nov 3, 2025
https://newrepublic.com/...

10. NY Post Exclusive – “Heritage Foundation in revolt over Tucker Carlson defense…” – Nov 3, 2025
https://nypost.com/...

11. Israel Hayom – “How the Republicans lost” by Liel Leibovitz – Nov 5, 2025
https://www.israelhayom.com/...

12. WritingTheRights Blog – “Tucker Carlson’s Populist Poison Laced with pro Nazism…” – Nov 2025
https://writingtherights.blogspot.com/...

13. Jerusalem Post – “Evangelical leader leaves Heritage…” – Nov 5, 2025
https://www.jpost.com/...

14. USA Today Opinion – “The Heritage Foundation made wrong choice…” by Dace Potas – Nov 6, 2025
https://www.usatoday.com/...

15. CNN The Lead with Jake Tapper Transcript – Aired Nov 6, 2025
https://transcripts.cnn.com/...

16. Mediaite – “Ex-Trump Adviser Stephen Moore Leaves Heritage…” – Nov 7, 2025
https://www.mediaite.com/...

17. X Post by @MichaelARothman – Bill Maher on Tucker/Fuentes – Nov 8, 2025
https://x.com/MichaelARothman/... | Archive

18. X Trending – Heritage Foundation Backs Tucker Carlson – Oct 31, 2025
https://x.com/i/trending/...

19. Pew Research Center – U.S. Religious Views on Israel – March 2025
(Referenced in NY Post, Nov 3)

[Freeleesy]

The fall out is still going on.

[Karliner]

The division is mighty. Guess who is laughing? The communists.

This is all sad. Tucker, Shapiro, Fuentes,Levin...all of them are opinion people, Opinions.

Anyone remember Trump was almost assassinated, Kirk was assassinated, we blew up Iran for Israel? Anyone remember the debt clock? The deep state?

We all need to step back a little maybe and find common ground because this is going to sink the who damned ship.

[ConservativeMind]

This is a nothing-burger blown out to a crazed proportion.

Getting mad someone didn’t say something about someone else’s interview?

This is equivalent to teen girls fighting over nothing.

[Kazan]

Getting mad someone didn’t say something about someone else’s interview?

There has been an orchestrated effort, led by Mark Levin, Dinesh D'Souza and Ben Shapiro, to cancel anyone that refuses to ostracize Tucker Carlson.

Staffers even resigned from the Heritage Foundation because Kevin Roberts refused to.

So, it's not a nothing-burger. It's cancel culture tactics from the GOP establishment.

[Milagros]

The bigger problem is Tucker, seeking to promote Darril Cooper and loco Nick Fuentes masking his promotion as "just asking questions." What a hypocrite liar.

[ConservativeMind]

Mark Levin has the most annoying whiny, nasally voice.

[Dartoid]

We blew up Iran for Israel is an incredibly stupid statement

[DoodleBob]

It was about 6 months ago when FR was littered with pro- and anti-Ukraine and Russia threads. The attendant Hatfield and McCoy factions spent oodles of bandwidth on, effectively, a conflict that had little to do with America.

It was basically, a distraction to the assault on life, liberty, and property in America.

NOW, that lot is nowhere to be found in any abundance. Why, it’s like they stopped getting paid.

In their place, we are being served daily anti- and pro-Tucker/Fuentes/other losers food fights.

Just like before, FR sees a waste of bandwidth debating the merits of these losers, while American life, liberty, and property remains in the balance.

Take this image, change some of the titles, and it illustrates this saga perfectly.

[Impala64ssa]

This is a nothing-burger blown out to a crazed proportion
It's like tribalism and it's nothing new. I remember when my dad was a committeeman for the local Republican committee and I was in the Young Republicans. The infighting within the party, as well as within the Dem party was worse than across party lines. Being new to this racket I thought Civil War II was gonna break out.

[Zathras]

Actually this sounds exactly like how the Palestinians have fractured support in Israel over the decades.
Arafat would fly in celebrities to “tour” Israel and only show them the occupied areas.
They would then go back home and tell everyone how evil Israel is.

For a very long time, southern Christians were very anti Israel until Reagan united both sides of the fence with our Jewish friends.

It is clearly back again and probably worse than in the 60’s.

[dfwgator]

I think the 1972 Munich Olympics was also a major factor in shifting support for Israel.

[Zathras]

A fantastic graphic of what has happened on FR since Obama.

[Zathras]

Very likely!
Most don’t even remember 1972 Munich.
Funny that the firearm company HK, designed several new weapons in response to 1972.
MP5
PG1

[x]

Roberts is like a college president who stumbles into some debate the academics are having. The college presidents know that their job is to raise money and spend money and not to intervene in academic arguments.

[cgbg]

“It’s like tribalism and it’s nothing new. I remember when my dad was a committeeman for the local Republican committee and I was in the Young Republicans”

Excellent post—saw the same thing with Young Americans for Freedom many decades ago...

There were some older and more experienced folks there who worked very hard to hold the “big tent” together.

We made it work without compromising any of our views—learned to agree to disagree in a civil way.

Name calling and demands for purity were absolutely off the table.

[ckilmer]

People are not anti israel. Rather they are pro american.

This controversy is dated. The reason is that Trump already made the peace in the middle east.

That peace did not increase his political capital. What he spent on that peace decreased his political capital.

But israel is safe enough for now.

The problem now is at home—just as Carlson points out. How do we know that. Witness the results of the Nov elections last week.

Trump has to spend the next year doing nothing but improving the lot of Americans and being seen as improving the lot of Americans. He can’t be devoting himself to foreign policy.

To many, he has been flying to close to the sun.

[Freeleesy]

Tucker needs to be sidelined

[Karliner]

Putin had him pegged as a college preppy that had delusions of being a CIA guy. After that interview I’ve never been able to take him serious but I like some of his interviews.

I don’t dislike him.

[Karliner]

We blew up Iran for Israel is an incredibly stupid statement

Who said that? Tucker?