‘This is really quite simple. By the time these biographers set about their task, most persons who would have the closest connection with Stanley Ann while she was pregnant (her parents, Obama, Sr., the hospital physician who signed Obama’s birth certificate, etc.) were dead. Yours is one very weak argument from silence.’
You claim a white woman married a black man in early 60s HI & became pregnant w his child. You claim she lived there 9 mos & gave birth, but no one, not one soul, remembers her. They don’t remember her living with Obama. They don’t remember her being pregnant. They don’t remember her giving birth/bringing a new baby home.
No, they’re not all dead. Plenty of people alive in the sixties are still alive. If Stanley Ann had done what you claim, someone would remember. The fact that NO ONE remembers her blows your theory to smithereens. I.e.: you say on the one hand that inter-racial couples were not common in those days; you say on the other that naturally anyone who might have seen her either doesn’t remember or is dead.
How do we know she never lived at the address listed in the bogus birth announcements? Because the daughter—the daughter, novel concept—of the people who lived there has stated it dispositively. She said neither Stanley Ann nor Obama Sr. ever lived there, and certainly Stanley Ann did not bring a new baby home to a place she’d never live [the daughter stressed that, not me].
So you cannot explain the bogus address on the bogus birth announcements, but you are confident Stanley Ann lived somewhere. You just have no freaking idea where.
Anti-birthers are...irrational.
So do all the biographers you listed. Can you name one person who has purported to investigate this who identifies some OTHER woman as Obama's mother? If there were a woman (or any of her family members) who could credibly claim she gave birth to a U.S. President, don't you think SOMEBODY would be out peddling the story? If true, it would be worth a fortune. But instead it's crickets.
The fact that NO ONE remembers her blows your theory to smithereens.
Dr. David Sinclair signed the birth certificate attesting to Obama's birth and that Stanley Ann is his mother. My theory is fully intact.
Again, in this country we customarily prove birth circumstances by having the relevant state certify to that. We don't demand state verification PLUS a photo of the "birth home." But being the true Birther you are, you insist on moving the goalposts till you find some point you think you can question.
So you cannot explain the bogus address on the bogus birth announcements,
Even supposing that address is incorrect, I have no need to explain it. The birth announcement (like Obama, Sr.'s INS file, the Indonesian school application, Stanley Ann's State Dept file, the 1990 newspaper interviews, and some other items along the way) simply corroborate what Hawaii has officially declared. Even if the newspaper birth announcements didn't exist, the evidence of Obama's Hawaiian birth would still overwhelms any alleged evidence of birth elsewhere.