Is There Growing Confusion over Church Teaching?

Crisis Magazine ^ | July 16, 2014 | Dr. William Oddie

[wmfights]

FWIW, the caucus label was removed BEFORE any non-Catholics posted comments on this thread.

Isn't this something.

Every time I've tried posting a Caucus Thread it's been challenged by RC's and I've had to go back and forth with the RM. The end result has been I post open threads and don't worry if the content details the failures of Roman Catholicism.

[metmom]

Every time I've tried posting a Caucus Thread it's been challenged by RC's and I've had to go back and forth with the RM. The end result has been I post open threads and don't worry if the content details the failures of Roman Catholicism.

They want to run the whole show.

They want the protection of caucus threads for themselves only and challenge others when they try to have their own.

How immature.

[verga]

How immature.

Almost as much as protestants continuing to beat up on this.

[Legatus]

They want the protection of caucus threads for themselves only and challenge others when they try to have their own.

Isn't that mind reading? And who exactly is "they"? List 'em. Of course you can't do that either because that would be making it personal. In fact me referring to you is probably making it personal, so for now on instead of writing "you" I shall write "penguins" or possibly "moose". So have fun penguins.

[Alex Murphy]

They want to run the whole show. They want the protection of caucus threads for themselves only and challenge others when they try to have their own.

And some refuse to trust the judgment of any moderator that is not known to be Catholic. I wonder if Protestants would be stripped of their right to vote, should our country become majority Catholic?

[metmom]

Every time I've tried posting a Caucus Thread it's been challenged by RC's and I've had to go back and forth with the RM. The end result has been I post open threads and don't worry if the content details the failures of Roman Catholicism.

With the longing for the return of the Inquisition that I've seen some FRoman Catholics express, that would only be the start.

[metmom]

Only faithful Catholics get to vote?

And what do we become?

A third world hell hole like the predominantly Catholic countries like the Philippines, Colombia, Brazil?

If the most highly Catholic cities and states in THIS country are any indication, that IS what we’d become.

Catholic monarchy? The RCC set precedent for hundreds of years.

No thanks.

[verga]

NYer--please begin a new caucused thread and warn all participants to not use it to attack other religions which are not present in the caucus.

NYer, I think ZC has a darn good idea here.

[metmom]

Well, now, that wasn’t so hard,, now was it?

Almost 300 posts and not one Catholic thought of the idea?

[Gamecock]

OSAS is NOT of Calvin. We Reformed folk don’t put any stick in it.

Just thought you’d like to know.

[Karl Spooner]

You guys should stay up here in the major leagues where you might learn something. That minor league team you all give suck on in protective custody will get you nowhere.

[Gamecock]

OSAS is NOT of Calvin. We Reformed folk don’t put any stick in it.

Just thought you’d like to know.

[Karl Spooner]

Quite simply, metmon follows the Word of God as best she can. You Catholics follow the word of man as best you can.

[defconw]

ROFLOL! Penguins!

[CynicalBear]

I thought you wanted us to leave you alone? Not a good way to start that. Catholics with their leadership all dressed up with black and white really shouldn’t start that penguin stuff.

[Legatus]

That’s why I raised the possibility of “moose”...

[Legatus]

Mynd you, møøse bites Kan be pretty nasti...

[defconw]

Moose! If you give a moose a muffin..... LOL.