Posted on 02/03/2016 5:59:48 AM PST by Cincinatus' Wife
The Illinois Board of Elections of Monday ruled on a birther challenge to Texas Sen. Ted Cruz's eligibility to be on the Illinois March 15th primary ballot. The board said that, "Further discussion on this issue is unnecessary." As they rejected the challenge, as well as another separate challenge against Sen. Marco Rubio.
Popular Grove lawyer Lawrence Joyce brought the challenge, he was one of the lawyers representing people in 2008 and into 2009 seeking to have Barack Obama disqualified from serving as President using the same birther arguments that were made against Cruz. Those birther challenges against President Obama were laughed out of every courtroom that heard them.
Joyce and other birthers like GOP presidential candidate Donald Trump, are of the belief that because Cruz was born to an American mother, while she was living and working in Canada, he is not a Natural Born Citizen of the United States, which is a requirement under Article II of the Constitution to be eligible to be President.
English Common Law(the basis of the American legal system), the nations first immigration laws, legal and Supreme Court precedent, and the fact that Cruz never had to go through the naturalization process all say that Ted Cruz was an American citizen at the moment of his birth, and is thus a Natural Born citizen. Not to mention the immigration law in effect at the time of Cruz's birth.
That last point about naturalization was cited by the Illinois Board of Elections in rejecting Mr. Joyce's challenge.
From the Huffington Post:
"The Candidate is a natural born citizen by virtue of being born in Canada to his mother who was a U.S. citizen at the time of his birth," the board said, reasoning that Cruz met the criteria because he "did not have to take any steps or go through a naturalization process at some point after birth."
A second birther challenge against Ted Cruz from one William Graham was dismissed by the IL Board of Education because of improper filing.
Cruz's Illinois lawyer Sharee Langenstein, a constitutional lawyer and 2nd amendment lobbyist, says that the Board of Elections agreed with her legal rebuttal to Joyce that a state agency has no authority to decide matters of federal law, in making their ruling in favor of Cruz.
By denying the birther challenges against Cruz and certifying him for the ballot the Illinois Board of Elections also affirmed that Cruz is a Natural Born Citizen.
Langenstein says that, "It's ironic that birthers think they know the constitution so well, but they file cases that deal with federal law in state administrative agencies that have no jurisdiction or authority to make that decision in the first place."
Constitution...we don’t need no stinkin’ Constitution!
As we knew it would.
Good. Fanatics and lunatics lose one... As they always do.
Can we move on now?
translation: We’re not going to entertain that until after he’s actually won.
This has NOTHING to do with answering the question.
Maybe this will be good enough to quiet the Donald on this issue? Doubt it!
The Rubicon has been crossed. The American republic is now in the rearview mirror.
What a relief! I was worried that we would have to repeat the John McCain primaries all over again.
Surprise, surprise. And right in Obama’s backyard. We can’t let the citizenship of a first term Senator, Harvard constitutional lawyer with only a single American parent, a dual citizenship whose records are sealed impact that of another first term Senator, Harvard constitutional lawyer with only a single American parent, a dual citizenship whose records are sealed can we?
Because as was demonstrated by Obama... NO ONE HAS STANDING to challenge this.
The courts have decided that the issue is up to congress to decide during the process of certifying the electors.
Any place that allowed the kenyan, who later renounced his already questionable "citizenship" to become Indonesian, and who attended college as a "Foreign Student", doesn't have a leg to stand on when it comes to Cruz.
I was under the impression that another candidate would have standing. If one of the other ‘pubs in the race won’t do it, then hillary could do it to gum up the general election.
From her jail cell?
First off this is a board of elections, not a federal court. Second, no where in the boards ruling is there any indication that either of the two petitioners lacked standing.
What on earth do we think was in the Founders’ minds when they wrote that, if not to make sure the president had no divided loyalties?
Perhaps all the good constitutional conservatives on this site have evolved to the point where they accept that born on the US soil of two non-US parents (Rubio), and born on foreign soil with only one US parent (Cruz), fit the criteria for natural born. I don't think either meets the qualifications — but then I'm old now and not up with the times.
Unfortunately Hillary’s attorney s are a bit tied up right now trying to keep her out of federal prison.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.