Lots of people do condemn Teddy and not just for hunting. Some condemn him for pushing a "living wage" and some other "progressive" ideas.
Lots of people condemn slaveholders, too.
People will condemn us someday.
Dead people don't care and the living shouldn't worry so much about how people will judge us in another century. It's really none of our business.
I blame Teddy Roosevelt for more than that. I blame him for being the catalyst that led to WW I and then WW II, the rise of the Soviet Union and the cold war. His third party run put Woodrow Wilson in office, and that led to all of the tragedy that we have faced since. If ever a US President should burn in hell it is Teddy Roosevelt, (alongside Woodrow Wilson, Franklin Roosevelt, Millard Filmore, and a few other still living presidents.)