Coolidge beats Reagan easily on immigration. And I doubt Coolidge made such horrible choices for the Sup Court that Reagan did with O’Connor and Kennedy.
Actually, Coolidge’s sole appointment to the Supreme Court, that of the sitting Attorney General Harlan Fiske Stone, was fairly lousy. He joined the left wing of the court in short order. FDR was so pleased with this “Republican”, he elevated him to Chief Justice when Charles Evans Hughes retired in 1941.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harlan_F._Stone
Who knows who he chose...
Don’t sell O’Connor short...she helped Bush in Bush v Gore