I, too, am a United Methodist pastor and a graduate of Asbury Seminary. I think (not positive) that my path has crossed that of Mike Allen at some point. I have one other friend (pastor) who has gone Catholic (Byzantine), and I'm in occasional contact with him. He was a courageous pastor, and it was a loss for the denomination when he went elsewhere.
There are some appealing things about the Catholic Church, but there are also a few that I doubt could be overcome; not the least of which is my calling into ministry.
Nonetheless, I consider myself in both the spiritual and kingdom lineage of those on whom hands have been laid since the inception of the church.
The website, http://enarefem.org/, is by a Methodist/Asbury dropout into the Catholic Church. Some of its articles might be useful.
A theologian friend once shared with me his personal opinion of John Wesley; he was so impressed with his life and sermons, he believed that if he had been raised a Catholic, Wesley would today be recognized as Saint John Wesley, and be named a Doctor of the Church.