Posted on 02/14/2019 11:29:00 PM PST by CondoleezzaProtege
Great post.
Perhaps she was. But she was also right about a good many things.
Not perfect, and wrong on several key issues, but that does not change the fact that she was right on a good many things.
L
The three movies that were made recently on Atlas Shrugged went from IMO:
1.Good - decent acting & quality looking production,
2.Average - Different actors with just a “so-so” performance, production quality off,
3.Awful - Again different actors, poor performance & another slip in production quality.
The Fountainhead with Gary Cooper is only worth watching if you’re a dyed-in-the-wool Copper & Patricia Neal fan and will watch anything they are in. Very poorly represents Rand’s book.
Well, they had 70 years to dress up as the wrong characters.
This form of criticism is akin to arguing (as the Left often does) that the Constitution is invalid because some of the Founding Fathers owned slaves.
There are several Randian ideas I’d advise them to stay well away from.
Regards, Viking
Much of her philosophy is great; her private life, horrible. Enjoy her books, but stay away from the real person.
There’s an old saying; “You become what you hate if you hate it enough!”
It applies to Ayn Rand and her group! I think the called themselves jokingly - “The Collective”.
And that’s what they become with the Brandens, latter Leonard Pekoff being the ideological enforcers.
Agreed. The first part of AS wasn’t too bad, but the second and third parts were almost unwatchable.
I think Atlas Shrugged just isn’t the right type of material for a movie. It is more about ideas, and railroads, steel mills and such are more of a background to the ideas. Movies need visuals to tell the story and Atlas doesn’t have them.
IMHO, it is cinematographic enough. The reasons are political. Hollywood hates the message. They are the bad guys according to Rand’s philosophy.
“A person wearing MAGA cap in Russia today is the least appealing promoter of anything right now.”
I’ve heard that Russia actually has pretty traditional values now. And I know I heard from visitors that they thought Obama was a horrible. They are totally against the gay agenda.
What would you think of a person wearing ‘Make Russia Great Again’ on your street? It is the same thing and has nothing to do with traditional values.
Also all the ‘Russia, Russia’ stuff has impact internationally, especially in Russia itself.
Agreed, better than Atlas Shrugged.
Yep, Hollywood would not even try.
“she may have kicked everyone out except Galt”
HA! That’s good!
I’m certainly no Rand or AS cultist. Though I can think of worse things than being a zealot regarding objectivism.
Probably more out of spite than admiration for Howard Roark I’ve made a pretty big move. I’ve got a little but I have no heirs other than a leftist sibling who gets zip. So, the plan is, upon death, to spend leftover money to bulldoze my properties and return the land to a condition unusable without work.
It does buoy my heart, lol.
Rand ping.
Not a cultist myself but AS explains the ways to success and failure quite well. It is a must read for sure.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.