Posted on 03/16/2018 7:00:31 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
The U.S. isn’t just politically divided -- it’s also economically divided.
New research says the two go hand-in-glove together.
There are the haves and the have-nots. Increasingly, the red states, which tend to vote Republican, are trailing far behind the blue states, which tend to vote Democrat, according to a recently published study. Worse still, the divide is getting wider.
This economic chasm helps explain president Trump’s rise to power, and why he could hold on to it longer than his detractors think possible.
“Generally, red states or the red areas of the country are lagging blue areas for employment even as the overall economy improves,” says Greg Basile, senior research analyst at the Washington, D.C.-based Institute of International Finance (IIF).
In other words, those record-low unemployment levels haven’t benefited all areas of the country equally.
Basile, along with colleagues at IIF, analyzed data on employment trends in the U.S. and combined the information with which way the population voted.
This is the second time that IIF has conducted the analysis. The first came last year. But this time, instead of just looking at the data from each state, the team dug far further into the weeds.
The analysts wanted a “cleaner representation of the red versus blue divide,” and so identified urban areas in red states that tended to have Democrat leanings. Such blue-leaning metropolitan areas in red states include Dallas and Philadelphia. (There aren't any red-leaning cities in blue-leaning states, the report states.)
In the simplest terms, the second-take analysis focused on the economic differences between urban and rural areas.
The results showed an even wider economic split than did the first take of the analysis.
“We find that the red-blue divide is more pronounced than in our first-pass analysis, with the employment-to-population gap even wider than we had first estimated,” states the IIF report "The Red-Blue Labor Market Split."
“There is no sign that the labor market, which is so buoyant at the national level, is helping to heal this divide. If anything, the divide is growing.”
Put another way, the urban-rural economic rift is even larger than the state-by-state difference.
It seems that the matter comes down to where various industries are located.
“The tribal political divisions of red versus blue is perhaps better understood as an intensification of the digital divide,” says Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at professional services firm RSM. He explains that the fast-growing technology industry and related business sectors show better productivity and higher wages.
In other words, the new economy (medical sciences, information technology, etc.) is boosting the blue areas of the country but not the red ones, which still rely heavily on traditional manufacturing or agriculture.
Newly created jobs in science and technology are going to the urban areas and the blue states, while job losses in traditional manufacturing are occurring in the red states.
As if that divide wasn’t bad enough, it is exacerbated by other matters. The much-heralded stock market rally, which began in March 2009 just as the financial crisis was ending, didn’t help everyone equally and neither did the housing recovery.
“The recovery in the U.S. has been driven by increasing assets prices for stocks and houses,” says Daniel Lacalle, chief economist at money management firm Tressis in London. But many in the middle class don’t own stocks and not all own real estate, so they didn’t see the benefit of the stock rally or the housing price rebound.
Plus, Lacalle points out that the middle class suffered increased taxation and higher healthcare costs. In other words, the boom in jobs left out substantial parts of the country, but so did the booming stock market and the recovering housing sector as well.
“In terms of the middle class outside of the hotspots [such as the coastal or urban areas], the difference between red and blue states is enormous, and it connects with reasons for Trump's success and Trump's views about the world,” says Lacalle.
More specifically, the fact that the red areas hadn't shared in the economic boom helps to explain why when Trump slaps tariffs on steel and aluminum imports he gets cheered in the heart of steel country. For instance, U.S. Steel recently announced it would restart blast furnaces in Illinois and thus add around 500 jobs.
These voters see Trump making changes that make a difference to the very workers who for too long got ignored.
As technology continues to allow people to work wherever they want, we will see more and more city people who hate the city move to rural areas and work out of their homes.
I’m an example of that. The technology is getting closer and closer to the “open the floodgates” moment.
Yeah, everybody is moving to upstate New York, Massachusetts, Kalifornia, and Illinois looking for work.
/S
Lies.
I guess the authors have never seen thr red-blue county map. Different lens, different analysis.
Bull, redstates on average have lower unemployment, Lower cost of living, and lower taxes.
RE: Yeah, everybody is moving to upstate New York, Massachusetts, Kalifornia, and Illinois looking for work.
I can’t speak for the other states, but here in NY, where I live, YES, I do see out of state applicants in the financial industry and technology ( silicon alley ).
To balance everything out, I also DO see a lot of retirees moving OUT of New York State ( only to be replaced by immigrants ).
New York is a full 1% higher unemployment than Alabama.
Get out now.
RE: Get out now.
In a few years when I retire.
I’ve been trying to get my Mom and Brothers out of Orange County for years. My Brothers work for UPS and Cintas respectively. It is crazy for them to stay and there and get reamed with taxes.
They must be measuring for the raw numbers of new hires. The “Blue” areas are seeing the biggest increases, because the job markets in those regions are more fragile. They’ve been depressed for years, and now are in a position to get “caught up”. Meanwhile, the Red regions are more economically stable, so companies there didn’t take as bad a hit and don’t need to hire as steeply.
Now that I think of it, the OP “analysis” sounds very Keynesian, since they don’t seem to account for not only differences in state economic policies that might keep Red areas more stable in downturns, but they also don’t account for different types of jobs in different regions. To the OP analysts, jobs are a generic unit.
I live in SC. We are doing just fine.
RE: New York is a full 1% higher unemployment than Alabama.
True. But that’s mostly in the depressed upstate New York area. There could have been significant employment gains had the state allowed fracking to proceed like they did in neighboring Pennsylvania but that idea was canned.
Here in Long Island where I live, unemployment rate tracks the national average.
The “1%” does well in Blue States. The rest of the people - not so much.
I recently took a road trip and am reminded that there are 1000s of small towns waiting to be energized by new citizens that will buy beautiful old homes and other real estate that have fallen into disrepair and can be had—comparatively speaking— for almost nothing. Lets’s just hope that when these new telecommuting citizens come (if they do) that they adopt the politics of small town America.
I was at Cedar Park Hobby Lobby yesterday. Customer in front of me was trying to hit the road to get home before heavy rush hour traffic, to Austin. I said we only have 6000 ppl in our town, one traffic light, and rush hour is when you see one other car on FM 1431. Way out in boondocks overlooking Lake Travis... in Lago Vista. Sh mumbled something in a demonic voice under her breath about me bragging... ha ha. We love It. out here her in Balcones Wildlife Preserve! Not crazy about the coyotes but had them in Claremont, LA county, too. We retired and moved out here!
Ppl on Fox News are always lamenting N Y home prices. Get outside of the city, I found an acreage in NY State,big two story house, $153k.
What we really need is the manufacturing back. That will re energize the red states.
Lets’s just hope that when these new telecommuting citizens come (if they do) that they adopt the politics of small town America.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.