Posted on 03/20/2016 5:32:47 AM PDT by SJackson
Israeli professor says Jerusalem should endorse Kurdish aspirations in war-torn Syria, can help defeat Islamic State
After the main Syrian Kurdish group officially declared areas under its control in northern Syria a federalized autonomous region this week, the Syrian regime and opposition, as well as Turkey, immediately rejected the declaration.
Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top stories Free Sign up!
The group was also not given a seat at the table of peace negotiations taking place in Geneva.
Despite not being recognized, the Syrian Kurds have fully governed their region for two years. Their governance has been overwhelmingly democratic, egalitarian and secular in a region where totalitarian and Islamist ideologies prevail.
The only other areas in the Middle East that can be characterized in this way are the Kurdish Regional Government (KRG) in Iraq — where minorities are well-protected under new laws — and Israel.
Aldar Khalil (C),from the Movement for a Democtratic Society, and Sheikh Hamad Sheikh Shihadeh (R), the Naim clan chief in northern Syria, speak during a meeting of more than 150 delegates from Kurdish, Arab, Assyrian and other parties in the town of Rmeilan, in Syria's northeastern Hasakeh province, on March 16, 2016.(AFP / DELIL SOULEIMAN) Aldar Khalil (C), from the Movement for a Democratic Society, and Sheikh Hamad Sheikh Shihadeh (R), the Naim clan chief in northern Syria, speak during a meeting of more than 150 delegates from Kurdish, Arab, Assyrian and other parties in the town of Rmeilan, in Syria’s northeastern Hasakeh province, on March 16, 2016. (AFP/DELIL SOULEIMAN)
“[The Syrian Kurds] are a community of people who are willing to cooperate with Israel,” Professor Ofra Bengio, head of the Kurdish studies program at Tel Aviv University, told The Times of Israel on Thursday.
There have not been any pro-Israel public declarations by Kurdish Syrians leaders, Bengio said, “but I know some that some have been to Israel behind the scenes but do not publicize it.”
Professor Ofra Bengio (Courtesy) Professor Ofra Bengio (Courtesy)
The Kurdish expert said that she has made personal contacts with Syrian Kurds who would like to send the message that they are willing to have relations.
“This is like the Kurds of Iraq behind the scenes. Once they feel stronger, they can think about taking relations into the open,” she said.
Israel has had a secretive relationship with the Iraqi Kurds, including limited military assistance, and Israel has been a willing buyer of the KRG’s oil. When the autonomous Iraqi region decided it would defy Baghdad’s orders last year and begin selling its own oil directly, Israel was one of the first countries to give the Iraqi Kurds the economic outlet and much needed money to fund their fight against the Islamic State.
A report by the Financial Times estimated that Israel had purchased 19 million barrels of Iraqi Kurdish oil, worth roughly $1 billion, between May and August of last year.
Iraqi Kurdish forces take part in an operation backed by US-led strikes in the northern Iraqi town of Sinjar on November 12, 2015, to retake the town from the Islamic State group and cut a key supply line to Syria. (AFP PHOTO / SAFIN HAMED) Iraqi Kurdish forces take part in an operation backed by US-led strikes in the northern Iraqi town of Sinjar on November 12, 2015, to retake the town from the Islamic State group and cut a key supply line to Syria. (AFP PHOTO/SAFIN HAMED)
Bengio believes Israel should move quickly to give behind-the-scenes support to the nascent Syrian Kurdish polity.
“This is the most effective party that can defeat the Islamic State and stand as a bulwark against it. The more ways we can find ways to cooperate with them the better for us,” she said.
Making a comparison to when Israel’s Arab neighbors immediately declared war on the nascent Jewish state after independence was declared in 1948, Bengio said, “The Kurds in Syria were a non-entity in 2012. In a few years, they have been building their state while fighting for it at the same time, just like what happened with Israel.”
“Israel can gain friendship with a party that is stable, pro-Israel, more democratic, more open and liberal. The role of women in Kurdish Syria is open, more egalitarian than any other place in the region,” she added.
In this photo released on May 24, 2015, provided by the Kurdish fighters of the People’s Protection Units (YPG), which has been authenticated based on its contents and other AP reporting, Kurdish female fighters of the YPG carry their weapons as they prepare for a battle against Islamic State fighters near the village of Mabrouka, northeast Syria. (The Kurdish fighters of the People's Protection Units via AP) In this photo released on May 24, Kurdish female fighters of the People’s Protection Units (YPG) carry their weapons as they prepare for a battle against Islamic State fighters near the village of Mabrouka, northeast Syria. (The Kurdish fighters of the People’s Protection Units via AP)
In June of 2014, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu expressed support of the Kurdish cause.
“We should … support the Kurdish aspiration for independence,” he said, adding that the Kurds are “a nation of fighters [who] have proved political commitment and are worthy of independence.”
The prime minister, however, did not specify whether he supported only the Iraqi Kurds, or the struggle of Kurdish minorities in Syria, Iran and Turkey as well.
More recently, in January, Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked called for an independent Kurdistan between Iran and Turkey, and urged an enhanced policy of cooperation between Israel and the Kurds.
Turkey, however, with whom Israel is going to great lengths to repair relations, is greatly opposed to the Syrian Kurdish independence movement. Ankara views the Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party, or PYD, as an extension of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK, which has renewed a decades-old insurgency since peace talks collapsed last year. The US also considers the PKK a terrorist group.
Turkish Kurds shout slogans in support of Syrian Kurdish fighters on the other side of the border near Suruc, Turkey, Wednesday, Sept. 24, 2014. (photo credit: AP/Burhan Ozbilici) Turkish Kurds shout slogans in support of Syrian Kurdish fighters on the other side of the border near Suruc, Turkey, Wednesday, Sept. 24, 2014. (AP/Burhan Ozbilici)
Bengio dismissed Turkey’s accusation that the PYD is a terrorist group. She said that even though the PYD is linked to the PKK, it did not carry out terrorist attacks, nor does the US label the PYD a terrorist organization as it does the PKK.
“Today, the PYD is working to stabilize what they have achieved since 2012. It’s not logical to believe they would open up another front with Turkey,” she said.
She added that despite Turkey’s opposition, the PYD has managed to receive the support of both the US and Russia.
Though relations between Syrian Kurds and Israel would be secret, Bengio believes that Israel should stand strong in its support of Syria’s Kurds and break the linkage between its relations with Turkey and that of the Kurds. She cited Turkey’s support of Hamas while it continues to have relations with Israel.
“Turkey supports Hamas that openly seeks to annihilate Israel. While this is still the case, Israel should at least have the right to provide humanitarian support the Syrian Kurds,” Bengio said.
Tamar Hussein Ibrahim, a Syrian Kurdish journalist currently living in Irbil in Iraqi Kurdistan, said that neither Israel nor Syrians Kurds should shy away from publicly declaring mutual support.
“Israel should openly support and endorse Kurdish aspirations in Syria and the Syrian political factions should publicly declare these relations. At the end of day, this will be good step for the stability and coexistence in the region,” he said.
“Israel can have a trustworthy and reliable ally in the new Syria and I think the Kurds are the ones ready for that,” he added.
If you'd like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
..................
Logic is that everyone would be better off if the Kurds had an independent nation formed from Kurdish parts of Turkey, Syria, and Iraq.
Good for the Kurds. Next step would be to open their borders to LEGITIMATE refugees and aid workers and share the burden and contributions coming into Jordan for doing the same thing. A Hashemite-Kurdish Alliance would be a logical next step to an independent state.
Turkey has begun bombing of Kurds in the Northwest of Iraq while troops are stationed several hundred yards into Syria in several locations to block any link ups.
And we’re still allied with Turkey? Wow.
The Kurds are as much entitled to a country of their own as are everyone else. Turkey needs to be pressed to ease this ethnic purging campaign which they even wage in other countries.
Will The One be disappointed with the Kurds over this?
You need to keep up with this stuff as Russia has said it might nuke Turkey after the US and Turkey vectored two Turkish F-16s to shoot down a Russian SU-24 bomber. That incident caused the Russians to install an S-400 system at Latackia the sight of which caused the US to immediately stop any sorties within its range since the US has no known counter.
Since Turkey is a NATO member: if Russia attacks Turkey, then the US (NATO) is obliged to defend thereby it starting WW III. However, if Turkey eggs Russia on - which they are trying hard to do - then any conflict arising NATO has said Turkey is on its own.
Anyone in the US who calls for a ‘no-fly zone’ in that area is basically calling for the start of WW III as we would have to take out the Russian AF to keep the handful of Syrian AF planes on the ground. That process would mean large losses of USAF planes including F-22s. Not something one should contemplate.
None of that mitigates Turkey’s continued support of Hamas and ISIS and it’s near genocidal tactics against the Kurds.
“Despite not being recognized, the Syrian Kurds have fully governed their region for two years. Their governance has been overwhelmingly democratic, egalitarian and secular in a region where totalitarian and Islamist ideologies prevail.”
Interesting how the left embraces Islamists but they ignore or even hate the Kurds. That is because most leftists are pure Marxists nowadays and they have abandoned any residual Western, liberal ideas they might have once had. It is all about who can help destroy Western civilization so the communists can have their “revolution” and build their utopia on the rubble of civilization.
President Biden would have given them a country years ago. He’s way ahead of the rest of us.
You forgot Iran.
Sort of seems a set up for fulfillment of Isa. 19 in the end.
They can become the new home for Middle East Christians as long as they are willing to fight for Kurdistan. They may just have to.
He'll be hyper-pizzed.
You can bet the Kurds wont be seeing much aid after breaking it of in 0 like this.
It is foreign policy like this that is so complicated that not listening to anyone but yourself is very, very, dangerous.
(ie: Kurds)
Just keeping it real for now. Wouldn't it make more sense for there to be a strong buffer state without getting Iran involved? One can't help but suspect that down the road, Iranian Kurds will find a voice....when they abut a strong, independent Kurdistan.
EMA (Eastern Minorities Alliance) marches on.
“[The Syrian Kurds] are a community of people who are willing to cooperate with Israel,” Professor Ofra Bengio, head of the Kurdish studies program at Tel Aviv University, told The Times of Israel on Thursday.
There have not been any pro-Israel public declarations by Kurdish Syrians leaders, Bengio said, “but I know some that some have been to Israel behind the scenes but do not publicize it.”
The Kurdish expert said that she has made personal contacts with Syrian Kurds who would like to send the message that they are willing to have relations.
“This is like the Kurds of Iraq behind the scenes. Once they feel stronger, they can think about taking relations into the open,” she said.
I agree that a solution for the Kurds is called for, but their terrorist suicide bombings in Turkey make them a lot less sympathetic.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.