Posted on 02/27/2014 7:01:13 AM PST by SoFloFreeper
Democrats believe they've hit on the perfect issue to distract from the horror of Obamacare in the 2014 elections: the minimum wage.
Apparently, increasing the minimum wage was not important for American workers during the first five years of Obama's presidency -- least of all his first two years, when Democrats controlled Congress and could have passed anything. (And did!)
No. The minimum wage did not become a pressing concern until an election year in which the public's hatred of Obamacare is expected to be the central issue.
As The New York Times explained, Democrats see the minimum wage as an issue that "will place Republican candidates in a difficult position," and also as a tool "to enlarge the electorate in a nonpresidential election, when turnout among minorities and youths typically drops off."
(Unlike Republicans, Democrats consider it important to win elections.)
To most people, it seems as if the Democrats are giving workers something for nothing. But there are always tradeoffs. No serious economist denies that increasing the minimum wage will cost jobs. If it's not worth paying someone $10 an hour to do something, the job will be eliminated -- or it simply won't be created.
(Excerpt) Read more at anncoulter.com ...
The minimum wage is the perfect Democratic issue. It will screw the very people it claims to help, while making Democrats look like saviors of the working class, either by getting them a higher wage or providing them with generous government benefits when they lose their jobs because of the mandatory wage hike.
Of course, the reason American workers’ wages are so low in the first place is because of the Democrats’ policies on immigration. Republicans might want to point that out.
Since the late 1960s, the Democrats have been dumping about a million low-skilled immigrants on the country every year, driving down wages, especially at the lower end of the spectrum.
According to Harvard economist George Borjas, our immigration policies have reduced American wages by $402 billion a year — while increasing profits for employers by $437 billion a year. (That’s minus what they have to pay to the government in taxes to support their out-of-work former employees. Of course, we’re all forced to share that tax burden.)
Or, as the White House puts it on its website promoting an increase in the minimum wage, “Today, the real value of the minimum wage has fallen by nearly one-third since its peak in 1968.”
Why were wages so high until 1968? Because that’s when Teddy Kennedy’s 1965 Immigration Act kicked in, bringing in about a million immigrants a year, almost 90 percent of them unskilled workers from the Third World.
Our immigration policies massively redistribute wealth from the poorest Americans to the richest. It’s a basic law of economics that when the supply goes up, the price goes down. More workers means the price of their labor plummets.
Unfortunately, politicians spend a lot more time talking to rich employers than to working-class Americans. And the rich apparently have an insatiable appetite for cheap labor.
Having artificially created a glut of low-wage workers, now Democrats want to artificially raise their wages.
It’s win-win-win-win-win for Democrats.
— Employees who get a higher minimum wage are grateful to the Democrats.
— Employees who lose their jobs because of the minimum wage hike are grateful to the Democrats for generous government handouts.
— Poor immigrants who need government benefits are grateful to the Democrats.
— American businesses enjoying the deluge of cheap labor are grateful to the Democrats.
— Democratic politicians guaranteed re-election by virtue of ethnic bloc voting are grateful to the Democrats.
Do Republicans have any principles at all? Why isn’t the GOP demanding an end to this dump of unskilled workers/Democratic voters on the country?
Democrats show how much they love the poor by importing a million more of them to America each year. But then they prevent the last batch of poor immigrants from getting decent, well-paying jobs by bringing in another million poor people the next year.
You want a higher minimum wage? Turn off the spigot of low-wage workers pouring in to the U.S. and it will rise on its own through the iron law of supply and demand.
In response to the Democrats’ minimum wage proposal, Republicans should introduce a bill ending both legal and illegal immigration until the minimum wage rises naturally to $14 an hour.
Australia has a $15 minimum wage for adults — more than twice the U.S. minimum wage. Meanwhile, their official unemployment rate is lower than ours: 6 percent compared to 6.6 percent in the U.S. — and that’s with a lousy $7.25 minimum wage.
Sound good? Try immigrating there. Australia has some of the most restrictive immigration policies in the world. Their approach to immigration is to admit only people who will be good for Australia. (Weird!) Applicants are evaluated on a point system that gives preference to youth, English proficiency, education and skill level.
Similarly, New Zealand will soon have an official minimum wage of $14.25 for adults. Even our Democrats aren’t proposing that! New Zealand’s minimum wage hit $10.10 — the Democrats’ current proposal for us — back in 2006. Their unemployment rate is also 6 percent — up from several years of 4 percent unemployment a few years ago.
Like Australia, New Zealand’s immigration laws are based on helping New Zealand, not on helping other countries get rid of their poor people, which is our policy.
Instead of training the citizenry to look at the government as our paternal benefactor, distributing minimum wage laws and unemployment benefits in important election years, why don’t Republicans put an end to the artificial glut of low-wage, low-skilled workers being imposed on the country by our immigration laws?
Republicans could guarantee a $14 minimum wage simply by closing the pipeline of more than 1 million poor immigrants coming in every year.
Businessmen will gripe, but maybe the GOP could explain to their Chamber of Commerce friends that they will help them by slashing oppressive regulations, reining in government bureaucracies, passing tort reform, etc. They’ll also be able to cut taxes because the welfare state will shrink, a result of Americans going back to work.
But if the plutocrats insist on admitting another 30 million Democratic voters in order to get ever-cheaper labor, then, soon, Republicans won’t be in a position to help them at all.
A fact lost on most people.
Just to be fair, why not bump ALL wages about 40%.
I spoke to a large business executive about a week ago. They do manufacturing. He said, “If they pass the minimum wage hike, we’ll be able to afford to automate several parts of our production.”
What? Afford to automate? What he meant was, since the cost of business would go up? They would have the financial excuse to invest in machines and software to replace workers. After explaining this he added, “...especially if they ever get around to enforcing Obamacare.” They think their ROI would be 3 years against the potential cost of doing business if minimum wage is increased and Obamacare is enforced. He wouldn’t say how many workers would be replaced. But he did say it would be transitional over 18 months.
This is how minimum wage and Obamacare work in concert to destroy our economy. His biggest concern is the penalties that are being written up for employers who cut the work force to save costs under the Obamacare law. (I’m not sure what exactly that meant).
It was pretty revealing.
I have yet so see ANY poll where this does not garner at least 65% approval from the sheeple.
Which really makes me wonder how it is Harry Reid can’t come up with the votes for this.
Most union contracts have a clause that gives automatic raises in the event of a rise in the minimum wage. That’s exactly what is pushing these ‘reforms’ to the minimum wage - union employees, having reached the point where job actions cause closures and who are unable to wrangle any more wages at the negotiating table are instead going all out to raise the minimum wage and thus raise union wages.
There you go - it isn’t to help the ‘working poor’, it is to help the unions.
Ann is spot on. Focus on the message not the messenger. Our immigration policies are destroying the American worker and making the Dems the permanent majority party.
Why is it that these ‘increase minimum wage’ stories never point out the obvious?
The reason the current minimum wage doesn’t buy enough in the real world is that there are too many dollars chasing too few goods. The main reason for that is the huge increase in salaries for government workers. Instead of raising the minimum wage, cut government workers pay in half. It would not take long for the price of goods and services to fall and people making $7 an hour could afford things again.
My presumption is the current delay for businesses that are being coerced into 'swearing' that cuts are not caused by the ACA. Otherwise, they incur a penalty.
I've heard something about that. The conversation moved on. I'm not sure if that is what he was referring to or not. But I suppose it's possible.
A friend of mine who owns a business simply said, if Obamacare is still here in 2015, he is shutting his business and moving to Florida to retire.
“If they pass the minimum wage hike, we’ll be able to afford to automate several parts of our production.”
Yes, not only is the cost of manual labor doubling, the price of automation is coming down, fast. They are on par now, without increased minimum wages, and without obamacare, the only thing missing is the initial investment. When your exec says “we’ll be able to afford to”, he is saying “it will pay for itself in one year”.
In the near future, the population of unemployed, propertyless underclass will explode to 60%-80%. We will either embrace eugenics, or becomes a walled society in the style of Brazil. No third option.
Huge increase in salaries for government workers? Since when?
I wholeheartedly agree with everything that you have said and I do have to run but one point that would help our cause on immigration woul be to bring in people from Eastern Europe
Because they are onto the Democrats. This would be how I would compromise and let’s face it the Republicans we have are a very sorry bunch.
When you speak of automatic increases, don’t forget the government. Prime reason for increasing the minimum wage is that it will increase taxes without passing a tax increase.
...and here, I thought I was making funny!
So, if you're working, who has time to sit around and answer polls?
This is what happened in the Central Valley of California. The United Farm Workers Union drove up farm workers’ wages to the point that it became possible to replace them with machines. (Turns out they had to replace the tomatoes being picked to a tougher-skinned, less tasty variety to survive the picking machine’s rough treatment). So raising the workers’ wages too much ended with the workers being replaced.
Occasionally we visit family in Costa Rica. Going into a Costa Rican supermarket is amazing. There might be 100 employees deployed through the store—giving out samples, explaining the product, basically waiting on you. At least 25 behind the butcher counter. But their wages are low. In an American supermarket, they’re starting to eliminate the checkers with self serve checkout. If the minimum wage is increased enough, you will certainly see that job disappear (along with countless other low-skill jobs as well).
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.