Skip to comments.Taking Swipes at the Smartphone Generation
Posted on 03/29/2013 12:38:56 PM PDT by Kaslin
The digital age continues to confuse and confound a generation of adults who have learned to participate in it, but lack the ability for what Ethel Merman as Annie Oakley called "doin' what comes naturally."
We still think a microwave is for heating coffee and thawing frozen food, never the name of a computer game. We weren't born to researching on Wikipedia or Googling for facts. Our fingers can text, but often strike two letters on the Android, making for some strange communications. We despair of catching up with the tools at hand and wonder what it all means for the future of our children.
With the wisdom that comes with age we question whether fast learning on a computer equals the understanding that comes from slower study in books. (We're suspicious of books on Kindle, too.) When teachers try to make learning fun with computers, will children grow up to take on the hard tasks for thinking things out? Inquiring minds want to know.
The latest fad for teaching is the video game Minecraft, a Lego-like building game for learning how to build structures. It made a splash as a way to teach students how to "dig deep." One private school teacher for 12-year olds uses it to design buildings for an ancient Roman apartment house.
"It's an accurate way to build things without just having to write down all this stuff," one child tells The Washington Post. "You still have to make floor plans, but it's more interactive and more fun."
But this approach enables a computer to drive the course. Is this how we want to take the kids in a virtual tour of ancient Rome? Virgil would not approve, and you don't have to be (an) ancient to wonder whether these children would travel deep into their imaginations or understand why Dido was disconsolate when Aeneas left her behind.
Besides, who said learning has to be fun? Learning is hard. Dancing letters and images can excite Sesame Street toddlers, but once they learn to read, the letters stop jumping and they have to shape up to learn the hard stuff, the meaning of metaphors, how to write a simile.
Joel Levin, co-founder of a company that helps schools set up Minecraft, hopes to work Minecraft into history, math, reading and art classes. An eighth-grader who plays the Minecraft game "Survival," which includes zombies and creepers, talks about how "cool" it is. "You can shape your own world." Cool in the classroom is exactly what we're suspicious of.
Hanna Rosin, writing in Atlantic magazine about "touch-screen learning," says two-thirds of children ages 4 to 7 have used an iPhone: "Touch technology follows the same technology as shaking a rattle or knocking down a pile of blocks." The child swipes, something happens. Norman Rockwell painted innocent children in an earlier age reading a book; today, he might paint their fingers swiping across a screen.
We don't yet know whether computers will change the way young people learn to think conceptually, but we already know how traditional subject matter is measured against the tools of technology. An acrimonious debate boils at the college level between pedagogues who think it's better to study for the B.A. and getting at least a smattering of what we used to call the Great Books, and young people who want to go from high school straight to programs offered at many community colleges to teach the technical skills in high demand. Many include working with computers. These skills promise better pay than a B.A. degree in the humanities can.
This is not an academic argument. There's a serious debate over whether Pell Grant programs, which fund part of the tuition for the pursuit of a four-year liberal arts degree, should be extended to cover job-oriented skills.
"If you want to take four years of Shakespeare, that's up to you," Anthony P. Carnevale, director of Georgetown University's Center on Education and the Workforce, tells The New York Times. "Is that what the public sector should support? The bottom line is, given the budget situation, we ought to be more concerned about preparing people for the job market."
Once upon a time, we had respect for the great books that expanded mind and imagination, the ability to think with insight. Now the emphasis is on tools, process not content.
The invention of the printing press put an end to illuminated manuscripts, but it spectacularly expanded access to information and literature. So it may be for the touch-screen generation, as words on paper diminish and disappear. We can always hope, but we're a long way from knowing what the impact of the digital technology will be on the brain. It may change the way we do what comes naturally.
watchit who youre dissing there kid
i just joined that smartphone crowd last week
Nana got cool dude
What's 'is name? ("Let's eat grandpa"?) Nana needs to get a comma.
I have an irresponsible nephew who bogied his 10 year long marriage because he wasn’t smart enough or mature enough to avoid the problems associated with using a ‘smart’ phone. I could slap him!
Just cause you got a smartphone it don’t make you smart.
Many older people don’t want to take the time to learn any new way of doing things, and younger people don’t care how it used to be done.
Quite frankly digging through encyclopedias was inefficient and boring. I always have to take the perspective that I hold the power of the whole world in my hand. If I have a question I just have to look it up.
Remember its not a POS smart phone, it is a marvel of modern technology that affords you such opportunities to learn new things while waiting for your food or other meaningless moments in life.
Beatcha by a couple of months.
Online teaching has already begun to eat away at the government school/teacher’s union/Marxist axis. Which is something that we FReepers have been praying for since forever.
Virtual school enrollment rising
Written by Mary Nash-Wood
Its 8:30 a.m. Monday, and SarahJayne Driskill is getting ready for school.
Admitting she isnt much of a morning person, she puts on a pair of skinny jeans and a navy blouse and comes downstairs in her Southern Trace home at 9 a.m.
The senior walks to her locker a corner in the family living room that houses her school books and laptop. As pens and a notebook fall from her locker, she laughs and quickly picks up the pieces.
Even with her at home for school, some things are the same and just like so many teenagers. Her locker isnt always the cleanest, her mother, Rachel Driskill, says.
The 18-year-old Shreveport senior is one of 268 students in northwest Louisiana enrolled in one of the states two free fully virtual public schools Louisiana Connections Academy and Louisiana Virtual Charter Academy.
As parents across the region look to virtual schools to meet their childrens needs, some say there is not enough data yet available to see if these programs are adequately teaching students. Over the past two years, students in Caddo, DeSoto, Bossier and Webster parishes who are choosing to leave traditional schools and selecting virtual programs far more than those moving to private or charter schools, and the number of students looking to virtual schools only look to grow.
Louisiana Connections Principal Caroline Wood said parents in northwest Louisiana consistently are applying to leave traditional public school systems and make the move to online charters.
The older I get, the more I value and put emphasis on genuine human interaction over technology-driven interaction.
ELSIE sometime IN a coma!
one of the nice things with e-readers is the instant ability to look up words and highlight w/o physical destruction. OTHO i am still more comfortable with a real book in my hand.
you can’t speed learn and retain. speed learning is cramming, in and out. real learning takes time and experience whetaher one learns better self-taught, in a classroon, via video or hands-on.
How widespread is this program?
We are smart. We look for things...
They will when the grid goes down...
These devices clearly demonstrate that; “You can lead a fool to knowledge, but you can't make him think!”
It is just getting started, but the interest is very high. A couple of people in my morning coffee group work in this field and they say it is growing exponentially. Costs per pupil are about 1/2 that of conventional schools.
I see it as a huge threat to government schools and the teacher union.
One observation here - “online learning” is not new. I’m 63, and a 1968 graduate of a North Louisiana high school. One of my classmates never set foot in a classroom all through high school.
He couldn’t, as he was paraplegic. These were the days before handicap accessible buildings.
The phone company set up a speakerphone where he could “attend classes” at home.
He is a college graduate, and has worked as an accountant and tax preparer ever since. I see him around town in a vehicle with hand controls and a wheelchair lift, driving himself around.
If you want to learn, you can learn. There is literally more information available at this point in time, than ever before in human history.
1. With one exception, the people who had the most difficult time coping during that time were the most "tech-savvy" folks in the office who were like fish out of water once the power/Internet/phone systems went down. The one exception was a twenty-something guy from a family of immigrants who was out and about in his family's neighborhood helping to clean up the mess.
2. The person who sustained the worst damage to his property was a 70+ year old guy who had a tree come down on his house. I didn't learn about how bad it was until after he had been back at work for more than two weeks.
3. With the exception of a few folks who consider themselves middle-aged "hipsters" and were no better off than their younger counterparts as described in #1, the people in the 40-60 age group had no trouble figuring out how to get by. One guy in his early 40s never lost power at home, but was so bored out of his mind that he drove all over the area looking for ways to lend help to others.
Maybe I'm being overly harsh here, but for all of the wonderful thigns these high-tech gizmos bring us, they've also helped to create a nation of coddled p#ssies.
I recently went to a dinner with some college friends I’ve kept in touch with.
All of us work in technology - network administrators, programmers, high level support, etc. All mid-40s.
We all had a chuckle when we discovered that none of us own a smartphone.
Several reasons - data plans too expensive, already in front of a computer with Internet access most waking hours, technology already inteferes with family life, etc.
Most with children did have text-capable phones, but no smartphones. And it’s not like we aren’t tech savvy or new-tech-adverse. Just a choice.
Inefficient, maybe, but boring? No.
While looking up how "bees" communicate, I would always stumble on something about Berlin or Bermuda or the Beech tree, or Beethoven.
It was inefficient precisely because of that.
I switched from an ancient Moto Razr to an Apple 5 right before Christmas.
It’s totally awesome. Heck you can use it to measure vehicle performance, the kind of stuff that took $10 grand in special instrumentation not that many years ago.
Heck, as a kid, I used to get under the covers with an encyclopedia volume and a flashlight .. good sleep aid and good prep for Trivial Pursuit .. but then Sometimers comes along and wipes out the hard-won gains .. lol
My daughters play Minecraft, almost obsessively.
I have, occasionally, thought of taking it up to see if I could build models of fortifications, like Ft. Sumter, Castillo de San Marco, or Moro Castle, or castles like Katz and Maus.
Quoth the "instant gratification" citizen of the net. Without critical thinking skills how does one separate the wheat from the chaff when using a search engine to "look it up"? In addition to the "power of the whole world" in your hand there is a very good chance that at least 50% of what is found on the net is "bovine excrement"!
I've been using computers as tools since 1963, so I'm far from being a "Luddite". Words define the limits of your ability to conceptualize and communicate a thought. If your vocabulary does not include a word how do you propose to look it up?
Best of luck in your endeavors,
2 Timothy 3:1-11 (KJV)
1 This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come.
2 For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy,
3 Without natural affection, trucebreakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, despisers of those that are good,
4 Traitors, heady, highminded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God;
5 Having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof: from such turn away.
6 For of this sort are they which creep into houses, and lead captive silly women laden with sins, led away with divers lusts,
7 Ever learning, and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth.
Many shall run to and fro, and knowledge shall increase.
When they finally do; you’ll find that your choices of a phone will be EXTREMELY biased toward the ‘smart’ ones.
With a builtin GPS to find you eaiser.
But now YouTube will show you some stuff that you might like to view...
Tom; just wait ‘til your TV breaks...
We just got a new one, and it’s really not a tv at all; just a computer that hangs on your wall with a little tuner built into it.
HUGE learning curve getting it up and running!
Then I’ll either do without or find one like it on ebay .. tho I’ve not checked lately, given their lack of ‘cool’ they’re likely dirt cheap.
Actually, about the only thing I'd miss these days is a fast net connection.
Obviously, the advert geniuses couldn't care less about folks like me .. lol
“Quite frankly digging through encyclopedias was inefficient and boring. I always have to take the perspective that I hold the power of the whole world in my hand. If I have a question I just have to look it up.
Remember its not a POS smart phone, it is a marvel of modern technology that affords you such opportunities to learn new things while waiting for your food or other meaningless moments in life.”
I agree with this entirely. It’s a tool, much like a wrench or a hammer. It increases and expands your capabilities.
Of course, if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
I was good at memorizing facts and working a library. Now I’m good at working Google and acquiring facts (and separating them from garbage).
Agreed. The “smart” in smart phone refers to the phone, not the user. I see lots of smart phone users that don’t even come close.
Speak for yourself,Suzanne. If a kid brings out a smartphone, I can whip out an iphone, ipad AND an ipad mini, all of which I use for just about everything including posting this!
I am the guy who relishes a little adversity. Gives me the chance to teach some survival skills when people would really want to pay attention. In most instances people passively listen when you talk about “surviving”. In those instances they actually listen.
I take to it well and just roll with it. Part of my personality I suppose. I don’t like to listen to whining. :)
Sounds like the internet, and I still didn’t get anything done. LOL
I was exactly the same way until I realized 99% of my students were using them, and that 99% of them now all communicate by texting. NO ONE calls anymore. I wold bet that 95% of my phone usage is now text.
I SWORE I wouldn't get sucked in, but like I stated, if you don't than you lose touch with the kids.
Now ask me how long I have WITHSTOOD that dang iPhone.......Droid for me baby...
How many students do you have? You must have at least 100 students, or else no less than 200, 300, 400, etc. Otherwise, what's 99% of, say, 256 students? There would be somewhere a half of a student "using it", as you say. Whad'ya teach?
Well, as I have no students, that's a tolerable loss
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.