So are you ready to accept the evidence that variation in a population can arise where it did not exist before?
Or are you going to deny the obvious evidence that such a supposition is ‘all wet’?
Sorry, no science stands on the ground that supernatural causation is the explanation for physical phenomena.
Why do you suppose that if something is random it is out of the control of God? Do you think HIS power stops at the casino door? Read the Bible.
The lots are cast into the lap - but every result is from the Lord.
Your observation, or "metaphor" would be spot-on, dear AMD, were it not for the fact that, as Einstein noted, "God does not play dice."
You claim to be a Christian. And yet you deny God has an active, ongoing role in this universe. That is to say, He is not only not Creator, but also not active Sustainer of all He created as well from Alpha to Omega.
But since He does not show up in your "experiments," therefore, on your crackpot logic, He does not exist.
You effectively make yourself the very measure of God here.
Why on earth do you think that is a good idea?
So you're ready to accept that God works by invading the material and manipulating the natural, material when it comes to craps, but not when it comes to weather or life?
Make up your mind, will you?