Athens School 'Attack' Proven To Be False, Girl To Be Charged(tawana brawley part deux)

KLTV.com ^ | April 9, 2008

[Dane]

There are major new developments today in the case of a supposed beating of a student from Athens Middle School.

Charges are being filed against 13 year old Melanie Bowers by Athens ISD through the Henderson County District Attorney's office for filing a false report, said AISD officials today.

Bowers claimed earlier this week that she was beaten and threatened - with killing and rape, no less - by a group of students at Athens ISD last Friday, for creating a protest sign saying, "If you love our nation, stop illegal immigration."

After Melanie's accusations, administrators reviewed school survellience videotape of the incident - which, instead of showing students beating or attacking her, showed Bowers scratching herself on her arms, face, and neck, and walking through the halls of the school calmly long after she claimed the incident happened

[Dane]

MY, my, my, right wingers(michelle malkin, etc) taking on al sharpton tactics, what has this world come to.

[Dane]

One pingy ringy, two pingy ringy.

[ARE SOLE]

And you have taken on Hillary tactics Dane girl.

[TightyRighty]

Did she make the posters that were distributed around campus too? Interesting.....

[Dane]

And you have taken on Hillary tactics Dane girl.

Uh no it seems that this thirteen year old girl has taken on al sharpton tactics(ala the tawana brawley charade).

[darkangel82]

Don’t you ever tire of spouting DNC talking points?

[spanalot]

“No one manipsmapes me”.

[fieldmarshaldj]

Daney always does have that nasty DU stench whenever it posts.

[Dane]

Don’t you ever tire of spouting DNC talking points? '

Uh Sir/Madame, I am not the one who championed this teenager's plight that could come straight out of al sharpton's playbook(tawana brawley)

[SF Republican]

Well that is a surprise; what is not surprising are those on this forum which attack the messenger.

[FrPR]

A good lesson for all of us. Everything I needed to know on this subject I learned from The Crucible. Children are children, and sometimes they are deeply insecure, deeply manipulative, and deeply untruthful and hateful.

Especially, if I may say, GIRLS.

Lying, sniping, cruel, manipulative, evil, beautiful GIRLS.

Girls STILL suck. One of ‘em even made me marry her.

I hope my son won’t be a nerd like I was !

[Moonman62]

She should be prosecuted for breaking the law, and so should all the aliens in our country illegally.

BTW, her sign really was taken from her.

[JRochelle]

So Michelle Malkin doesn't believe that the girl made it up after the contents of the tapes were viewed?

I highly doubt that.

Malkin believed the girl. I doubt that will continue.

[happinesswithoutpeace]

Wow, according to the article even the dad agrees that the charges should have been filed. o_O

[Free ThinkerNY]

Michelle Malkin posted this info today on her blog. She’s hasn’t tried to cover up anything. Sharpton perpetrated a fraud that was 1000 times worse than what this girl did. There is no comparison.

[Dane]

Michelle Malkin posted this info today on her blog. She’s hasn’t tried to cover up anything. Sharpton perpetrated a fraud that was 1000 times worse than what this girl did. There is no comparison.

Well to her credit, she hasn't tried to cover it up, but to her discredit and IMO, michelle malkin was salivating like Pavlov's dog in hoping this hoax was true.

[Question_Assumptions]

The parents are doing the right thing and not trying to defend what she did or fight the punishment.

[ModelBreaker]

MY, my, my, right wingers(michelle malkin, etc) taking on al sharpton tactics, what has this world come to.

And, they are just as stupid.

[muggs]

She should be prosecuted for breaking the law, and so should all the aliens in our country illegally.

BUMP

[Toddsterpatriot]

This is terrible. I guess we shouldn't try to control our borders now?

[Charles Martel]

Why have you started more than one thread on this?

[Dane]

This is terrible. I guess we shouldn't try to control our borders now?

Who said we shouldn't control our borders? I guess in your Absolut world, this consciously perpetuated hoax would have never happened.

[Toddsterpatriot]

Who said we shouldn't control our borders?

I thought you did? Maybe I misheard you?

Just to be clear, you think we should control our borders?

[Dane]

Just to be clear, you think we should control our borders?

In your Absolut world or not?

[Toddsterpatriot]

Next time, some might want to verify that the story is true before jumping to conclusions.

Which conclusions did some jump to? That illegals go to that school? That students sometimes attack other students? That students sometimes lie about attacks? That some illegals react poorly to signs like the one she displayed?

[Migraine]

I saw nothing about Michelle Malkin in any of this post. I read the headline and the blurb and the article and still don’t know where this took place. I wondered at first if it were Athens, Greece (the only Athens that deserves to be mentioned w/o stating anything further regarding locality).

[Toddsterpatriot]

In my world I think we should control our border.

I'm asking about your world.

[Jeff Chandler]

This is more proof that Hispanics and illegal immigrants are being scapegoated in today’s America.

Aye Chihuahua!

[ozarkgirl]

Interesting development. For once, you get a chalk mark on your side of the board. Must feel pretty good. Had I been on your side of the board, I’d feel pretty good about it too. Absolut! ly

[Dane]

In my world I think we should control our border.

I'm asking about your world.

Is the below your world?

JMO, the above was not Ronald Reagan's world.

[Toddsterpatriot]

No. Now that we have that out of the way.....do you think we should control our borders?

[NathanR]

That wall was to keep Germans in. The wall we want is to keep foreigners out.

[Dane]

No. Now that we have that out of the way.....do you think we should control our borders?

What do you mean out of the way? Are you going to follow Ronald Reagan's legacy or not.

[Toddsterpatriot]

Many jumped to the conclusion that the girl was actually attacked and threatened

Well, she said she was. What jump was needed?

and that her attackers were illegal.

Right, she said they were Hispanic, some jumped to the conclusion they were illegal. Do any illegals go to that school?

Apparently, you are stilling jumping to the conclusion that the latter is true.

She wasn't attacked. How could she have been attacked by illegals?

Where is your proof?

Of what?