Three of the 99% who give the 1% a bad name |
||
 Melbourne Mills |
 Shirley Cunningham, Jr. |
 William Gallion |
Posted on 08/11/2007 12:21:16 PM PDT by Daffynition
Melbourne Mills' face went from shock to disbelief yesterday as he and co-defendants Shirley Cunningham Jr. and William Gallion were ordered out of a Covington federal courtroom to jail.
Just seconds earlier, U.S. District Judge William Bertelsman granted the three suspended lawyers' request to delay a criminal trial until January but immediately revoked the suspended lawyers' bond.
As Bertelsman walked off the bench, Hale Almand Jr., a lawyer for Gallion, began to protest as the courtroom erupted. Bertelsman cut him off.
"I told you that's what I was going to do," Bertelsman said as he left the courtroom.
Mills, Cunningham and Gallion, who were indicted in June on one count each of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, were being held at the Boone County jail last night and may remain there until the January trial. The three suspended lawyers, who used to practice in Lexington, had been free on their own recognizance since June. Defense attorneys for the three men declined to comment on whether they would appeal the decision.
Mills, 76, Cunningham, 52, and Gallion, 56, are accused of taking $64 million of a $200 million diet-drug settlement that should have gone to 440 clients in a 2001 Boone Circuit Court case.
In 2004, some of the former clients sued the three men in civil court, demanding a full accounting of the settlement money. In 2006, special Judge William Wehr ruled that the suspended lawyers had breached their fiduciary duty to their clients. Last week, Wehr ordered that the three men should have to repay $42 million plus interest to their clients. Wehr also delayed a September civil trial that would decide punitive damages until after the criminal case against the three was completed.
Bertelsman's decision came at the end of what was supposed to be a routine status hearing on whether defense lawyers for the three men were going to be ready for an Oct. 15 criminal trial. Defense lawyers told Bertelsman that it was unlikely that they were going to be able to meet the first deadline in the case because of the volume of evidence federal prosecutors had accumulated during the investigation: more than 100 boxes containing 200,000 documents.
Stephen Dobson III, a lawyer for Cunningham, told Bertelsman that a contractor who was copying the documents for the defense would not be able to get the documents to the lawyers until the first week of September, weeks after the Aug. 20 deadline for the defense to file motions challenging the government's case.
But Bertelsman said he didn't understand why the defense needed all 200,000 documents to prepare their defense.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Laura Voorhees said there were 440 individual client files and records from the Kentucky Bar Association, which temporarily suspended the three lawyers last year, as well as financial records from 25 to 30 banks.
Bertelsman said he hesitated to grant a continuance because the civil case has been delayed until the criminal case was completed. Jim Shuffett, an attorney for Mills, said the civil case should not be a consideration because it's far from over. A motion filed in June is asking the Court of Appeals to overturn Wehr's March 2006 decision saying that three suspended lawyers had breached their fiduciary duty. Shuffett said he expected more motions to be filed with the Court of Appeals in coming days.
Bertelsman then told defense attorneys that if he delayed the trial, he was thinking of revoking the bond of the three defendants. The judge then gave defense lawyers a 15-minute recess to consider their options.
When Bertelsman returned after the recess, he told Voorhees and the defense lawyers that he had concerns about how the delay would appear to the public.
"In my opinion, not only are these three men on trial; the whole legal profession is on trial," Bertelsman said. If the trial is delayed, he said, it may appear that the legal system and Bertelsman were part of a conspiracy.
Voorhees told Bertelsman that she believed that the defense lawyers should be granted a delay so they could adequately prepare their defense.
"We don't want this case to be overturned on appeal," Voorhees said. The prosecution also never asked that the men's bond be revoked or that they be sent to jail.
Bertelsman said the three lawyers, if they are convicted, face 20 years in federal prison, not to mention the loss of millions of dollars, so it was in their interest to delay the trial. Regardless, Bertelsman granted the motion, delaying the trial until Jan. 7, and then abruptly remanded the three men to the custody of the U.S. Marshals.
Shuffett said after the hearing that the defense lawyers were going to meet to discuss their options.
"There is recourse available," Shuffett said, but declined to say what that recourse may be. Defense lawyers for Cunningham and Gallion did not return calls asking for comment.
The three suspended lawyers can ask Bertelsman to reconsider his decision and ask for a hearing to determine bond, or they can directly appeal the decision to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Angela Ford, who represents more than 400 former fen-phen clients in the civil lawsuit, said Bertelsman's decision reflects the outrage that many lawyers in Kentucky feel about this case.
"He's a very well-respected, no-nonsense judge. It sounds like he was sympathetic to the effect the delays have had on the victims," Ford said.
Yet John Edwards is still a free man, destroying the environment with his mansion.
What a bright, shiny day!!
Oh, it should be bumped again. Grant the delay, and revoke their bond! LOL!
Three lawyers in jail. The longest journey always starts with the first step.
L
This is historic. [sadly ...LOL]
I don’t know if these “Lawyers” are guilty or not. But knowing what I now of most Lawyers... I’d have to say they probably are.
Having a few Liars in jail can’t do anything but improve the Legal System in my opinion :P
It should create an incentive for their attorneys to work a little faster, don’t you think? :)
The defendants may want to consider suing their representation for malpractice.
Justice! Finally!
First Nifong, and now these attorneys. Maybe you do get what is coming to you in this life.
A hack saw? A gun carved from a bar of soap?
If you’re implying that we could someday see all corrupt lawyers in prison,then we had better start building a lot more prisons now.
Couldn’t happen to a more deserving crew. Melbourne Mills, jr, is a professional ambulance-chasing pirate of many years’ experience. It’s finally catching up to him.
It wouldn’t surprise me to find that this is the tip of the iceberg.
I’d like to see Bill O’Reilly commend this judge. As an attorney, the judge knows first hand what slime the defendants are!
LOL
“Shirley Cunninngham, Jr.”??? Is that a guy? Who would name a baby boy “Shirley”???
Time to jail people. I hate the too.
It’s a start, but probably won’t catch on - sadly.
I, as a member of the profession, have little sympathy for those who violate the clients’ trust and steal their money.
Good riddance!
sure....ever heard a song, "A boy named Sue"
I know, A guy named "Carrol".
Shirley Povich,a male, was a sportswriter for the WashPost for years.
Shirley, Doris, Doloras, Evelyn, Beverley, Vivian and a host
of other so-called girls names were at one time, names assigned to males.
Lawyers are the lowest forms of life.
there....fixed. :D
Stop calling him Surely.
(re: "Airplane")
Let’s start with Congress and the Senate!
frankly....
the lawyers, should be banned thought out the law making process....("I gotta protect my turf" mindset).....in adviser status only.
and the laws should be written in standard English....we need tort reform.
Thanks, RPL. :)
It sounds like you don’t know many lawyers. The lawyers in Kentucky are in the front of the lines cheering for these three scumbags to get sent up the river. These three were an embarrassment to all of us long before they ever got involved in fen-phen.
Mills and Cunningham were the jokes of the state bar - the guys who had obnoxious commercials shrinking dinosaurs with fireballs from their hands and stuff, but who couldn’t practice a difficult case to save their lives. They would take primarily only cases with clear liability, serious injuries, and insurance to cover it - easy money for almost no work. Gallion has long been known to some in the bar by the name “Sleaze”. I first became aware of him when he sued a bouncer who had kicked him out of a strip club, and he resisted. People like that don’t realize when they are humiliating themselves.
They are the reason people think and write things about lawyers like you wrote. The sooner their public disgrace is followed by a long imprisonment, the better for the legal profession.
The biggest slip and fall lawyer of all in this case got away clean, Stan Chesley.
Chesley gave huge contributions to the Arkanbillies and, helped to raise thousands to the Clinton campaigns.
Three more to soon run for office on the Democratic ticket.
bump for publicity
You’re not alone.
“Bertelsman’s decision reflects the outrage that many lawyers from Kentucky feel about this case”
Nice news to wake up to
Three of the 99% who give the 1% a bad name |
||
Melbourne Mills |
Shirley Cunningham, Jr. |
William Gallion |
It was right the first time...
If their clients are no longer with us, since so many fen-phen victims have passed, where will that money go then?
The limitless nature of greed is always astounding. If these gents had played by the rules, they would have pocketed a legal $20 million each. but that wasn’t enough.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.