Posted on 12/06/2006 11:01:05 PM PST by Aussie Dasher
A longtime aide to Jimmy Carter has resigned from the Carter Center think tank, calling the former president's new book on Israel and the Arabs one-sided and filled with errors.
Kenneth Stein, the Carter Center's first executive director and founder of its Middle East program, sent a letter that bluntly criticized the book to Carter and others.
Stein wrote that the book, "Palestine: Peace, Not Apartheid," was replete with factual errors, material copied from other sources and "simply invented segments," according to an excerpt of the letter published by the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
Deanna Congileo, Carter's spokeswoman, said the former president stands by the book.
Stein, who is also director of the Institute for the Study of Modern Israel at Emory University, did not immediately return a call Wednesday.
Carter issued a brief statement saying that Stein had not been actively involved with the center for more than 12 years and was not involved with the new book. Carter did not directly address Stein's allegations.
It is not the first time Carter and Stein have disagreed over Middle East policy, said Douglas Brinkley, a professor of history at Tulane University and the author of the 1988 Carter biography, "The Unfinished Presidency."
"They've never been on the same page in the Middle East. They've been in an almost constant state of disagreement," Brinkley said. Stein "doesn't trust the Palestinians as much as Carter."
Brinkley said he has read Carter's new book but would not address Stein's accusations.
It warms the heart to finally see Jimmy get a taste. It's just a shame that it comes so late to the old bastard.
Coward
Jimmy Carter is a disgrace to the USA.
Regards, Ivan
*snort* I LOVE "Blackadder"!
Whole parts of his presidency were "Invented segments".
I'll never forget this idiot sitting there with a sweater on and telling us we must do the same to conserve energy.
But I guess the sweater *is* the symbol of the DNC.
Whole parts of his presidency were "Invented segments".
I'll never forget this idiot sitting there with a sweater on and telling us we must do the same to conserve energy.
But I guess the sweater *is* the symbol of the DNC.
How does Jimmy Carter have any credibility on foreign policy after letting Iranian college students hold Americans hostage and then making a phony pact with Kim-Jong Il that bought him enough time to build a nuclear weapons program with American money?
I bet Jimmy is glad Hellary is now running for POTUS. He now stands to lose his title as worst President of all time. On the other hand, maybe he is is proud of that title judging how he acts.
Running out of holes to move pegs down into.......
In this case I'll go with Stein.
I mean where have they shown any signs of being trustworthy?
"A viler evil than to murder a man, is to sell him suicide as an act of virtue." Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged
In this case the Palestinians take the cake on both evils, murder and murder suicide. We call it terrorism, folks, and there is no justification for this evil inflicted upon innocents.
Stupid is as stupid does ...and says, Jimmah's case here.
Some of us have long known that Jimmah talks out of both sides of his peanut hole.
Whew! I thought for a minute this may have referred to his book "Ah'll nevah lie to you".
Well, at least he didn't lie here. Jimmuh just blatantly made up facts.
Seems like Jimmah has not only sin in his heart when he reads books like Playboy but also when he writes books. Hehehe.
Carter is an anti-semite and a racist. Time more people stood up and spoke out.
The wrong Carter brother died young. The older Jimmah gets, the more obnoxious he becomes, but there's always a book mill that will let him publish his screeds.
Carter won't admit anything.
Trust?
The Palestinians?
To say nothing of the wrong Kennedy brothers!
Carter used to carry his own luggage on and off planes to show he was a 'common' man but the truth is, it was empty as the suit he wears.
Jimmah is the worst EX PRESIDENT of the USA and is making Useless Grant look good in comparison!
This ought to ensure that Jimmy will get the Nobel for literature, also (his accomplishments in that field about as legitimate as they are in "peace").
Grant was a failure as a President....but....his memoirs are considered to be one of the great works of American literature and the greatest war memoir since Caesar wrote his Gallic Wars some 2,000 years earlier, in Latin.
So, in a sense, yes, Grant's retirement was a miserable failure as he was broke and cancer ridden. But...his retirement was also arguably the most successful of any US President in history. History has its ironies, I suppose.
At least Grant did something useful before he became President. In his memoirs he details his military service, but leaves out his Presidency, which is just as well.
Very true and a nice history lesson. My son just finished studying the Civil War for his social studies class. Jimmah remains a uniquely terrible ex president who doesn't know when to shut up!
I was just thinking the exact same thing.
It's too bad he'll probably always be insulated from the knowledge of exactly how despicable a large segment of humanity finds him.
I think Jimmah Carter has invented most of his whole life....
He is such a disgrace to America.
He is an excellent example of "the good die young".
Sounds as tho his sweater has finally totally unraveled!
Trust?
The Palestinians?
Mindwarping, isn't it?
But Carter always has "America's" best interests in mind. Always.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1642205/posts
It is my dream to someday write an historical piece that Doris steals. Apparently, it's not all that difficult. If she likes something, it's hers.
Kinda like Chinese Patent Law.
Dr. Stein was on Fox news during the past few days and totally exposed Carter's book. He stated the book was based on unvarnished analysis by Carter, it was replete with factual errors, copied materials and maps were not cited, superficialities, glarring omissions and totally invented segments of what he (Carter) wanted a situation to be. Dennis Ross, a Fox news anaylist on Israel and the middle east said the maps in Carters book never existed until he(Ross) created them. Carter said he got the maps out of a map book.....sic!! Carter needs for someone somplace to stick a soc in his mouth, and banish him to his rocking chair on the front porch on the peanut farm. Everytime he opens his mouth he hurts America. He is an ex president, but doesn't know how to keep his mouth shut and in time of war, that is dangerous!
Doris Kearns school of writing, uh?? Wonderful..seems like all the Democrats send their ex presidents to that school...Clinton graduated summa cum laude..but I must say his writings were a little more colorful. Seems they need a few more classes on how to copy a little better..we should check with Ms. Kearns on that!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.