Posted on 10/17/2004 7:23:07 PM PDT by SmithL
You Vols and War Eagles can duke it out for 3rd! ;-)
"But, from what I've seen thus far, it is clear to me that of LSU, Oklahoma and 'SC, the Trojans were clearly the real champs last year."
Sorry, this years teams are not last years teams. It is a shame USC didn't come to the dome for a real test.
LOL!!! A "real" test? LSU barely beat Oklahoma and they had just gotten SPANKED! They coaches and sports writers all know who the real national champ was last year. How much can a team change in a year, that it already has two losses with half the season still remaining?
Each team in the top three had a real bad spanking by a team they should have beat.
True, but for SC and LSU those losses were early on. Oklahoma was chalking up huge wins and had no excuse for blowing it at the end of the season, when championship teams are supposed to be peaking. Anyway, it'll be nice if we can get two undefeated teams battling this year. USC can't keep having close games like they have been lately, though. Personally, I didn't like the BCS even before last year's controversy. I like the "sudden death" feel of college ball. Every game matters and one loss means you're out of it. In pro ball, they can have 4 or 5 losses and still have a shot at the Super Bowl. How un-motivating is that?
"How much can a team change in a year,"
Do you really watch college football?
Not all of it -- only the teams/games that interest me. My point is, LSU was struggling from game one this season and has already lost 2 games and we're only halfway through the season. I realize that it is very rare for a college team to repeat as National Champ. But for LSU to have this poor a showing, only 8 months after winning the championship, makes it pretty clear to me that last year was a fluke for them. And, frankly, I think USC is failing to dominate at the moment. I don't think they should be #1 right now, but I hope to see them in contention for #1 by the end of the season.
Your point is legit for this year, but you cant take anything away from LSU last year. They won the coveted BCS trophy, and no one can take it away, even though the BCS and west coast stack AP wish they could. So they change the rules until they get it right. Good Luck, maybe this year.
They should either give extra points for teams from conferences with conference title games or penalize those that don't have one.
They should go ahead and let USC know they are in the title game - their next 4 opponents have a combined 7-17 record, then Notre Dame and UCLA, who are semi-pushovers.
Go Boise St. and Utah!
What happens if 6 teams finish undefeated?
Good point on conference title, then we would have had LSU/USC for the title, no co-champs.
6 unbeaten? there is alot of football left.
Strenghth of schedule should have more of a role. You can't play a lessor schedule while others play top 20's and claim greatness.
Not the trophy
If I'm not mistaken, one of the commentators was Bob Greise. You have to remember where he's from; then you will understand the negative hype....
(He is generally a good guy however. I am a fan of his. He has had a hard life but has made good.)
The BCS remains fatally flawed. Two-thirds of the vote is based upon poll rankings. The same teams appear in the top 25 year end and year out during the pre-season polls despite graduation losses or potential strength of schedule. Therefore, unless one starts as nearly Top 10 or better, they will not get in the title game as it is too hard to climb to the top starting any lower than that.
The Orange Bowl this year, for the title, will go to two of the schools forever ranked in the top 10. No one can break in to steal the spotlight.
Examples: A team like Fla St can lose its first game, but by week # 6, be right back in the mix (in the top 7 now) as it is today again by week # 6 of the season.
A team like Purdue can lose at the end of a game on a fluke play in the 6th week to another good team, and will have no chance to climb back into the picture, despite its ONE loss. Why? Because Purdue it not a traditional top 10 team.
That is in no way a "real bad spanking." And we see that Cal's season last year was no fluke. They are better this year and could end up in the top 20.
Go mama go!
LOL! Not that I'm biased or anything!
LOL! We don't need the trophy! The fact that USC was ranked #1 in all the preseason polls shows that everyone knows who really was the best team last year.
Watch out for Texas A&M. They will challenge OU, and they WILL beat Texas this year. Next year they will be a legit NC contender. Franchione is getting it done in College Station.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.