Posted on 01/25/2023 1:46:34 PM PST by nickcarraway
They definitely were the first to put Manchester on the map.
The Hacienda.
Actually, Steve was competing with Barney (Bernard) for her affection. Bizarre Love Triangle.
That’s socialized medicine for ya. Kind of like Obamacare...
So what was punk?
And what was pre-punk?
But I thought he sang “I’ve never looked at you in a sexual way in my life before…” on Touched By the Hand of God. That is one funny music video.
Sex Pistols. Ramones. Clash. Siouxsie and the Banshees.
They were punk.
Punk and New Wave were synonymous for a while.
When record companies staring signing safe crappy bands they began to use New Wave because it was less scary than punk.
My point is that the “post-punk” label for Joy Division seems like splitting hairs. All the members of the band knew of these other contemporaneous bands. But I’m thinking it was some influence happening, and some natural overlap.
But “rock journalists” can’t allow that, of course. Everything must be neatly compartmentalized.
But there are worse things than rock journalists. Try reading sports journalists. (But not on an empty stomach.)
Kind of.
Punk and New Wave were the same thing in 1977/8.
Later a distinction was made when the mainstream consumers became interested.
There’s no such thing as post-punk, really, but it would apply mainly to British bands that were punk but began experimenting more.
Like say after 1978.
I’d say post punk means after the Sex Pistols when things opened up in music and bands could do anything.
It means after breaking the msn monopoly on Rock Band crap like Journey, Led Zeppelin, Eagles, etc…ad nauseum.
Here’s the difference between punk and new wave back in the day.
Punk was tea party/Maga. New Wave was Rino/GOPe.
Early everyone was in the same boat. Differences became more apparent over time.
Punk was like the hippies, it really only lasted about a year, and then everybody became a “poser”.
Yeah it got mainstreamed.
I went to a lot of shows back then but I dressed like a normal college student that I was at the time. None of the outlandish dress bothered me much except at one show someone showed up and planted themselves right behind me and he was in a wheelchair dressed up like Dr. Strangelove. That made me do a double take. That era was like an endless Halloween.
I’ve only heard that one on Pumped Full of Drugs. It didn’t seem that the Nips cared for it.
Closer - what an album
https://thequietus.com/articles/28578-joy-division-closer-review-40th-anniversary
Whenever my son played “Tarantula” at his epic parties, it was time to go home. He only put it on when he was wasted, lol.
[...Ian Curtis a prisoner of his own body, and he took his own life at age 23.”
I believe he killed himself just before kicking off their North American tour. Love both Joy Division and New Order.
Coincidentally, I bought Pet Shop Boys/New Order tickets for a show in Chicago in 2020. The concert was cancelled due to Covid, and then delayed to 2021 and then to 2022.
My wife and I attended the show last summer, FINALLY, and it was amazing. You forget how much those two bands shaped the 80s and 90s.
Unforgettable show, and New Order ended with “Love will tear us apart.”
Winning!
That was a good read.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.