I recommend that New Yorkers print a copy of this ruling and carry it with them as their Concealed Carry Permit.
I used to recommend carry a copy of the Bill of Rights or the Second Amendment, but the cops and courts don’t seem to recognize those anymore.
No, they just roll their eyes and inform you that they are not going to allow any Constitutional arguments, merely establish guilt in the matter before them.
Unfortunately your 1st statement nullifies the 2nd; if you have a ‘permit’ it’s not a RIGHT.
We should all be free to carry (per the 2nd), backed up by the reciprocity of the Constitutional carry States (AK, AZ, etc.); but I’d keep a copy of all the ‘no duty’ lawsuits in m pocket Constitution JUST in case.