Skip to comments.The Other Reason The Fed Is Terrified Of A Government Shut Down
Posted on 09/24/2013 9:24:35 PM PDT by SatinDoll
While some have argued that the Fed is flying blind, given their endless efforts to convince the market that their actions (or inactions) are now all data-dependent - what happens when that data simply does not exist? As SMRA notes, the official word from the BLS [Bureau of Labor Statistics] is that they are working under the assumption that there will not be a government shutdown and the employment data will be released as scheduled; but what happens if the un-negotiation reaches beyond October 1st? How will our central-planners know what to do?
Via Ray Stone of Stone McCarthy,
The official word from the BLS is that they are working under the assumption that there will not be a government shutdown and the employment data will be released as scheduled.
That said, the Bureau does recognize that there is a risk of a shutdown and such could have implications for the timing of the Employment Situation release, and possibly other releases depending on the duration of the shutdown.
If there is a shutdown, the BLS won't be able to tell us when the employment data, and other key economic reports will be released until after the shutdown ends.
If the Federal Government shuts down on October 1 some BLS employees will report to the office to provide for an orderly shutdown. No new work will occur, but computers will be shutdown to prevent problems. Those workers that worked from home or in the field will be forced to turn in laptops, and BLS provided cell phones.
A shutdown will interfere with the processing of the employment data, and depending on the duration could very well lead to a delay in the release.
Specifically, the prospective October 1 shutdown would be the Tuesday of the week in which the employment release is scheduled. Most of the work on the Household survey (unemployment rate, etc) should be completed by this time. But, as of Tuesday there will be much to be done to prepare the establishment (payroll data).
Typically, the Monday of this employment week is that last day for the collection of responses to the survey. On Tuesday and much of Wednesday the establishment data are processed, and checked. This process is usually completed by late Wednesday afternoon. On Thursday the Employment Situation release is crafted. And on Friday the data are released at 8:30am eastern time.
Should the possible shutdown last only one-day (Tuesday) it still may be possible to release the employment data on Friday. But if the shutdown is anymore than one-day a postponement of the release seems likely.
The BLS will require a few days beyond the shutdown to process the data, quality check the numbers, and prepare the release. Thus, the release of the employment report will be at least a few days beyond the reopening of the government. Remember, no processing, quality checking or report preparation will occur during the shutdown.
The exact timing of the employment release will not only depends on the timing of the reopening of government, but also on the timing of other BLS releases. Conflicts with other indicators will factor into the timing decisions.
The December 1995-January 1996 shutdowns and January Blizzard, which shutdown Washington DC for a few days, caused a delay in the release of the December 1995 Employment Situation release by 2 weeks. Other economic statistics were also delayed. Moreover, the collection of survey data used to compiled the January statistics to be released in February 1996 was compromised to a degree.
The December 1995 employment release came out on Friday, January 19, 1996. The loss of processing time, did not allow for revisions to be made to the November 1995 data, but did provide for the routine revision to the October 1995 data. Due to the delay the BLS actually had more time to collect responses to the December 1995 payroll survey. The response rate for that report rose to 69.1% for the first closing on December 1995 payrolls, up from 56.6% in December 1994.
In a more serious tone, my nephew was told he no longer has a job after this Thursday, 9/26/2013, due to the approaching Federal shutdown.
He performs maintenance on low income housing. His job is budgeted by the State based on Federal money available. It was a little over $10 an hour and to many that isn't much. But I only earn about $350 per month from private party sales and with an EBT card we've managed to survive.
I'm sure he can get another job and if the economy was better it would be a certainty. I'm almost 62 and four more months until SS kicks in.
Why do we need such data more frequently than quarterly?
The BLS should be a major target in cutting spending.
An excellent question when you consider the number of times the Unemployment new-files weekly get adjusted in the weeks following. Last weeks was messed up because a large district (I don’t think they ever said) had a “glitch” so didn’t report. That caused the Unemployment new-files to under-report.
Just one of many ways to jigger the stats.
We might not be able to control everyone’s life.
I didn’t think I needed a /sarc tag. Sorry.
“Why do we need such data more frequently than quarterly? “
When I was in high rate production and there was a problem the tippy-top management demanded ever more frequent data snapshots. They believed that having more and more data was management. Then, they’d direct me to do sometimes ridiculous things based on data that was constantly moving. The real trends were not visible in the ever increasingly small snapshots. (This might not be the best example but think of the data as being snapshots of a flock of flying birds. You draw a line across the picture and sometimes there’s more above than below, but it’s essentially not relevant. If you want to count the birds do it once a quarter while they’re in stead state and you have a better picture.)
I really fail to see how a bunch of bureaucrats who constantly spend their time throughout the years fudging employment numbers not being able to continue that practice will somehow cause a problem.
All they need do is dust off last year’s lies and change the year...same difference.
We are not getting the truth, anyway.
Sounds peachy to me.
It's a casino with employment "data". It's a casino without. Why would I care?
Invest in real businesses, over time, slowly and carefully.
Look, it’s right there in Article 1, section 8: The government shall provide falsified employment data on a weekly basis to help keep a Fed-primed stock market going up.
< /sarcasm like a 2x4 to the head >
I agree with you completely.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.