Posted on 01/11/2015 7:45:13 PM PST by Pelham
“One responder to my previous post, Notes on noir, asked why so many movies are called film noir when, by my lights, theyre not. The simple, somewhat cheeky answer is brand creep: film noir is a bankable label for a crime movie, so its come to be liberally applied.”
I thought Citizen Kane was long regarded as a pioneer vehicle for film noir in America (it’s a bio-pic melodrama, not a crime film). And the German expressionist film before that included fantastic elements (the sort found in Sci-Fi, Fantasy, or Horror films).
Film Noir to me are dark and brooding with seriously flawed and conflicted protagonists, often scratching and clawing to stay even. And then there’s the Dames ... can’t forget the Dames.
Many can list the classics, but how about the more contemporary
I’’m no expert but I would like to see others list some of their own contemporary Film Noir.
Chinatown — Too bad it was in color.
Bladerunner — They managed to do it with dark and brooding atmospheric color. I don’t consider it dystopian more than I consider it Film Noir.
Dark City — The reverse of Blade Runner, more Dystopia than Film Noir.
L.A Confidential — barely registers as Film Noir in my book.
Basic Instinct — would have been great without Jennifer Lopez
The American — Clooney for the win — unless it’s politics.
Body Heat — I’m still angry.
made a mistake. Basic Instinct didn’t have Jennifer Lopez, that’s another film that shouldn’t even be on a list of potential film Noir.
Out of sight.
D.O.A.
‘nuff said :)
Good article. Thanks for the post!
“Double Indemnity” Best noir in my book.
Great movie, if you're talking about the original. Everyone involved with the dreadful 1980s remake should be shot.
Another classic: The Big Clock, with Ray Milland.
Sounds more like a hijack of the term "film noir" which at its core is defined by film technique, not story elements.
The elements under discussion are more of a dime-store paperback trade than pulp or the crime films of the 30s (which focused in the pre-code era on the rise and fall of gangsters).
Paperback fiction (whether the books were originally hardcover or not is irrelevant) can be typified by Mickey Spillane and other crime novelists.
Even Mike Hammer's Kiss Me Deadly wouldn't fit the blogger's definition of film noir.
I find this image to be both noir and the embodiment of a dimestore paperback cover.
Body Heat is a great modern noir. Probably my favorite. Or a tie with Blade Runner since you’re including it in your list. It certainly has the atmosphere. Sci-fi noir.
“Chinatown Too bad it was in color.”
Ha- good point. It might be better in a stark b&w
“Basic Instinct would have been great without Jennifer Lopez”
Did you mean Sharon Stone?
And have you ever seen ‘Hammett’? I’d include it with contemporary noir. Hard to find a copy but worth the hunt.
Agreed on all counts.
A while back, I was into watching some Italian giallo, which is similar in subject and execution, albeit different stylistically.
Bava’s “Blood and Black Lace” comes to mind.
Good pick. The writer agrees with you in his first blog post on noir:
“The purest noirs Ive seen so far are Double Indemnity (1944), Detour (1945), Decoy (1946), and Raw Deal (1948). “
A link to his first post:
https://www.chroniclesmagazine.org/notes-on-noir/
Thanks for the link.
Don’t forget my favorite, Out of the Past.
Disagree about “Chinatown” the color treatment positively accented the scenes and gave a dated richness to the film
Great picture of Double Indemnity. Another bonus was that Fred McMurray and Barbara Stanwyck were conservatives. Stanwyck grew up a poor orphan in Brooklyn New York and hated Roosevelt. She felt as if she could make a success through hard work, others could as well. I imagine it must have been hard for someone of her background to be preached to by a guy who was born with a silver spoon in his mouth (FDR) about how to help the poor...
I didn’t know that about Barbara Stanwyck, thanks. One can only imagine the conversations she must have had with Fred McMurray between scenes.
Another thing about Stanwyck is that her and hubby Robert Taylor testified at HUAC as a friendly witness testifying about all of the communistic influences in Hollywood. Taylor was another good conservative. But those were different times. A time when Hollywood had a lot of it’s top stars, producers and directors as Conservatives.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.