Skip to comments.American Idol 2012--Live Thread
Posted on 01/18/2012 11:41:39 AM PST by silent_jonny
Im wondering if she is his beard. Hey, stranger things have happened
An evolved type of guy?
Jerky Panda and I reacted the same way.
Oh sorry, Honey. I’ll plug you back in, in a minute.
“Beard” was the first thing that came to mind here.
At the risk of jinxing the progrram....Does everyone notice that as yet, we have not had to suffer through those arm flapping idiots in the front row tonight?
They have him on a studio mic...large diameter condensor... even with the screen. That will add some quality to a vocal....
I don’t know. The tabloids have gotten pics of them with their 3 foot long lenses strolling on some exotic beaches and playing kissy-face.
I have no doubt about the guy that just pranced around the mansion, however.
I’m liking this P2 song.
P2 is toneless.
The comments remind me of the Emperor’s New Clothes.
They were on the Voice in all their glory last night. Perhaps, they are just plumb tuckered out.
Well, that explains that overly long commercial for that movie. Thanks. I was wondering what was going on.
I agree... I do think that was his best song in about 5 weeks. But I wouldn’t buy it. I would love to hear Simon’s take on this guy...
Randy stole some Horses cool down Blanket , and is wearing it as a Jacket.
Shankman has been a judge on Nigel’s other show.
Round #2 finally begins.
P2's choice is "Volcano" by Damien Rice. Not familiar with this song, but he's doing a good job with it. The lights are dimmed. A cellist plays to his left. A single back-up singer on his right. Perfect.
The Ferlies listen in rapt silence.
That was really excellent.
Steven: I heard the musician that time, man. I never heard you sing like that before. I could listen to that before. Bee--u--tee--full.
J-Lo: Very few people could have pulled that off. A real testament to you. One of the most beautiful poignant moments ever on this show. Really lovely.
Randy: That's what's up right there. You are your own guy. That's one of your best performances of the whole season. Sometimes a simple statement has the most volumn.
I’m in the minority here but I like P2. I thought he did a great job with this song!
He is my favorite judge on So You Think You Can Dance!
I have a hard time listening to a 16 yr old (Jessica) and Hollie (whatever age she is)...singing about deep emotional love and hurt...........hell, when I was their age, the only hurt I knew was when dad wouldnt give me the keys to the car! I just do not buy “teenagers” singing torch songs.
I echo what someone else said last week, he is good at what he does, as is Joshua. But forcing them into these theme or genre nights isn’t good for them. P2’s second song was worlds better tonight, IMO, because it was more “him.”
Randy Jackson prediction of winner
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.