Posted on 01/18/2012 11:41:39 AM PST by silent_jonny
Who’s Comin’ With Me?! :)
Skylar and Jessica are called up.
Iovine calls Jessica's "Proud Mary" a travesty. Said her short tight dress made him uncomfortable. "Too mature, too racy. I think it's going to hurt her."
J-Lo explains why she didn't have umbridge with the dress.
Jessica is safe?? Skylar is in the bottom two with Hollie.
Well there goes that Finale idea 
UGHHH!!!
Skylar AND Hollie?
WTF?!?!
Jessica’s performance was dismal last night!
Expecially a 16-year-old hooker.
OY.
Ready for another round of fun?
I was. But these results are going to suck, either way.
14 minutes left in the show. What else is there left to do?
No sooner do I type that then pre-recorded Coldplay returns to the stage.
Yeah. This really stinks.
didn’t this crappy band already play tonight?
Good GAWD! How bout we send Coldplay HOME and keep Hiollie and Jessica!
On another note....if they do a reversal and have the couch sitters become the bottom three....they will be some kind of POd thinking and being TOLD they were safe...zthen NOT.....(Ryan better watch his back, if that happens!)
Evening, Cudjo! :)
My guess is that Skylar will go home tonight. Idol really couldn’t have another country singer win! (or come in second!)
Retro picked the perfect night to be gone! Coldplay TWICE...ARGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dang. Not happy with these results. I’m beginning to think the judges are going to get the Jessica/Joshua finale that they obviously want so much.
Hi, SC! :)
Coldplay is crappy. Well, P2 may have a future as a fill-in for the lead singer.
Dang. Not happy with these results. I’m beginning to think the judges are going to get the Jessica/Joshua finale that they obviously want so much.
I just sent hubby to the basement. He doesn’t like Skylar—thinks she’s too nasal. I didn’t want to hear him gloat. I didn’t remind him that Idol was on, either.
I know. Bad wife.
Lead singer seems a tad effeminate. (not that there’s anything wrong with that)
Oh darn!
This really sucks no matter how you look at it.
For once I am glad I am reading the play-by-play instead of watching.
Okay... I just gotta say... this is easy music. Guitar lick is a nothing. Chord progression is nothing. It’s just simple and I have no clue what the lyrics were. YET... it was better than Carrie tonight :)
I think Cold Play’s lead singer needs to PEE really, really, really BAD!! Hope there are no exposed electrical cables when his bladder blows. Mabe Ryan will get in the way.
Exactly.
Phillip is going home.
a TAD????????? LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!
And brilliant lyrics....!!
SOng one: Pair a Pair a Pair of dice
\Song 2 “Every Tee Uh Tee uh is a waterfowl”
LMAO
Dang. Not happy with these results. I’m beginning to think the judges are going to get the Jessica/Joshua finale that they obviously want so much.
They would be elated with that outcome.
If it that or those two and PP going for the finale We will watch just to read this thread and mute the performances when they are singing.
Never fired a gun in my life; never even held one. TODAY I BOUGHT A GUN!!!!
You're now a 2nd Amendment Mama! Congratulations! :)
My husband doesn’t like her either because she is too twangy. And we live in Texas!
My husband doesn’t like her either because she is too twangy. And we live in Texas!
Hollie looks like Sandy at the end of Grease tonight.
Who will it be Hollie or Skylar?
Randy: This is the best Top 5 we've ever had.
He may be right.
Steven: The Top 5 has never been better than this.
And the one going home is ...
WHAT THE---!?
Did not expect that.
Skylar still may have the best career of any of them...
Is every other commercial for Marshalls or TJ Maxx. All we need is a Kohl’s spot and we will have a trifecta.
Just Damn! BUT....Skylar is going to do GREAT! Im guessing she has already signed a multi buck contract with Nashville producers!
Dial Idol COMPLETELY blew it! Wow.
I hate this stupid show...sigh...
Well this sucks.
I believe “Fortunate Son” sunk her this week.
Well, people won’t have to worry about splitting their votes between Hollie and Skylar anymore. Hollie, if she keeps it up should get Skylar’s votes.
She’ll be big this time next year. Probably the only one who will make it. Sure hope so.
Same. He doesn’t like the twang thang.
OH WOW.
Skylar will be just FINE! She will get a contract in country music tout suite!
Now it’s full-on HOLLIE for this chick!
Bôôooooooooooooo boooooooooo she was the best entertainer of the bunch!
Skylar is dressed like the kid in Legend of Zelda.
I think you’re giving the voting audience too much credit. It’s more shallow than that. Phillip stunk up the joint, and he may not be in the bottom two next week either.
I think you are right and wasn’t that an Iovine pick?
Skyler just has fun energy, too bad she is gone.
LOL!
Next week Phillip will do his own version of “momma’s don’t let your babies grow up to be cowboys”.....
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.