American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[slugbug]

Yeah me too unfortunately...I like him so much better than Elise

[Fishtalk]

I think that’s a very effective commercial as well.

That running thing still creeps me out. Whatever PR firm came up with that should be fired.

[georgialily]

Your analysis is right on. I like Joshua’s powerful voice very much. He still seems to be uncomfortable up there in the spotlight, though.

Holli has a huge voice, but somehow, it doesn’t connect. I think she is trying too hard.

Elise is run-of-the-mill to me. I’ve heard singers like her at dozens of wedding and on numerous cruises.

I believe Elise should go home this week.

Jessica is topnotch, and she will succeed with or without AI (think Cat MacPhee and Pia Toscano.)

[Shelayne]

I hope not. I usually like him. But one bad night can do it.

[twin2]

I meant jonny. Fat fingers on the kindle fire tonite

[Netizen]

Maybe he takes milk thistle to protect his liver. Our vet even has me give it to our cat.

[silent_jonny]

Then don’t watch this musical number.

LOL--you should avoid all performances on tonight's show.

[retrokitten]

That could be.

[Shelayne]

Now THIS is drama!

[silent_jonny]

"No chump love, sucka!"

Phillips2, Colton and Jessica are called up.

Iovine regrets Sanchez singing songs that are too old for her.

He's 50-50 on Phillips.

And he's disappointed with both of Colton's performances.

J-Lo's voice sounds like a wind-up monkey clanging cymbals. Shut-up!

Sanchez is safe!

Colton and Phillips stand alone. One is in the Bottom Three.

It's Colton! (I'll go along with that)

P2 is safe.

Colton Dixon

[RummyChick]

Colton is out

[Fishtalk]

Well you were right.

Elise is safe?

This is fourth time she’s been in bottom.

[Netizen]

hopefully Colton is gone

[silent_jonny]

ELISE IS SAFE!

So it will either be Colton or Hollie.

Since a sing-off now would be pointless, Seacrest can push the drama to the last minute. And we break for commercial.

Go home, Skunk!

[twin2]

I fear Colton is leaving to. Had been hoping for Elise to finally exit.

[MagUSNRET]

Lesson learned for Colton....FORGET the bleeding skunk look!

[RummyChick]

[patriotspride]

J-Lo’s voice sounds like a wind-up monkey clanging cymbals. Shut-up!

---

I knew it reminded me of something..... Great description. :) :)

[silent_jonny]

THANK ME!

Thank you! ;)

[retrokitten]

It would be funny if Elise made it all the way to the #2 spot always being in the bottom 3.