American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[kjam22]

Yeah... I hope your wrong though. I’m liking Elise more all the time.

[retrokitten]

Have a great time! I can’t believe Tahoe still has snow! We hardly had any in Chicago this year.

[MagUSNRET]

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I LOVE that movie...so much so...that my parents go out to a Chinese restaurant with friends every Christmas Eve before church

[silent_jonny]

Hi, SC!

How's little SC doing? :)

[peggybac]

LOL love it!

[Shelayne]

Hollie for me tonight. Her “Rolling in the Deep” was amazing to me. I was worried when I heard she was going to sing that one, but she floored me.

Go, Hollie! :^)

[Clint N. Suhks]

So only one goes home even after the SAVE?

I find it hard to believe they can program an extra live show without more notice?

[silent_jonny]

Seriously? Yikes. Who else is judging?

Spears was the only name I heard. TMZ interviewed Simon over the phone and he said he hopes Britney agrees because she's "exciting". The TMZ people laughed that off. They know he only wants her because she's a younger, more trainwrecked version of Paula.

[silent_jonny]

LOL! I’m glad I wont have to watch. :)

Me too!

[Clint N. Suhks]

Love Hollie and Skylar too but I worry the 12 year old chickies will keep voting for Colton.

[MagUSNRET]

that...and Brittnays fake tits havent sagged as much as Paula’s have over the years ;-)

[Miss Didi]

Ha—my sister just emailed that Colton tonight was Liberace meets Twilight. I’m still watching, following the thread and voting at the same time. And eating chocolate. ;)

[Shelayne]

They had a contestant earlier in the season kicked off—remember “The Gentle Giant”? So, they are probably right on schedule.

I just hope they aren’t going to throw one of their begathons in there somewhere. Groan.

[Clint N. Suhks]

The drums/drummers on “Rolling in the Deep” were very cool.

[freedumb2003]

I am hoping Josh or Dave Matthews go — it is only fair.

I don’t think any of the women did well on song #2 except Skylar, so it sort of evens out.

None of the women deserve to go, although most of them don’t deserve to stay.

Thanks Jonny for continuing to be the host with the most!

TTFN, all

[retrokitten]

Ah, I forgot about that. You would think they would hype the drama of two going home.

[Shelayne]

I like Colton. LOL. I just thought he had an off night tonight.

I am NOT a Ferlie, however. ;^)

[Miss Didi]

I’m with your SIL...I LOVE P2!

[retrokitten]

Ha—my sister just emailed that Colton tonight was Liberace meets Twilight.

LOL! That is totally it!

[Clint N. Suhks]

“The Gentle Giant” was a felon right? I have to admit everyone left now is very good. Even Colton.

[Miss Didi]

The violin guy was stalking her on stage—ha!

[Shelayne]

That—and a crybaby. :^D

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Free!

[Clint N. Suhks]

Mrs Suhks likes Colton too, methinks you both are channeling your inner 12 year old chickie.

Did I just say that? :-O

[silent_jonny]

Didn’t like Colton’s song or performance.

Me either. I didn't like either of his songs tonight.

[silent_jonny]

Isn’t this the same song Phil^2 has sung for the last 4 or 5 weeks?

LOL, I was thinking the same thing.

[silent_jonny]

Howdy, J! :)

[Shelayne]

Well, he DOES have a nice smile. ;^) I like his voice and USUALLY really like the songs he sings. I also like P2. Tonight, though, I give it to Hollie with her first song.

Good stuff.

[silent_jonny]

his proctology appointment faces

Haha!

[stylecouncilor]

Little SC is such a good baby. She started smiling last weekend! :)

[stylecouncilor]

Colton tonight was Liberace meets Twilight

LOL!!

[Netizen]

Jermain was disqualified so when he left it evened everything out.

[Shelayne]

Ooooooh, she is so cute!

[Netizen]

aw very cute

[stylecouncilor]

Thank you! She’s been good about napping during Idol the last few weeks lol.

[peggybac]

But Paula's OUR trainwreck!

[peggybac]

Soooooooooooooooooo adorable!

[Shelayne]

What a good baby! LOL!

[Shelayne]

What a good baby! LOL!

[stylecouncilor]

Thank you. She’s a keeper!

[Clint N. Suhks]

Good catch.

Admit it, Idol is rigged, all the Judges are scripted and it doesn’t matter how well they sing on the show because they judge from the rehearsal, and I won’t be mean to you again.

Just kidding, you are a nice person I see from your posts and I apologize being mad at you before.

[slugbug]

Awww, your baby is adorable!

[skateman]

Send Samchez home, PLEASE!

[skateman]

Or Sanchez, also Philip Philips.

[skateman]

Or Sanchez, also Philip Philips.

[ken5050]

When Skylar started singing “I heard it through the grapevine..” I was waiting for Joshua to come out as one of the California Raisins..

[ken5050]

Random observations:

1. Hollie was superb tonite. Love to hear her sing more Dusty Springfield...she'd rock "You Don't Have to Say you Love me"...and any ANYTHING by Bonnie Tyler...imagine her doing "Total Eclipse of the Heart."..I'd buy that CD

2. Colton's first appearance..he looked like Edward Scissorhands

3. When ( and we know they will soon..) make a movie about Obama's life..Joshua can play young Obama..just look at those ears...they are carbon copies of Obama's..

[Netizen]

Dial Idol has Colton at the bottom, but who knows.

[Netizen]

That would be a very good song for her.

[stylecouncilor]

Thank you. :)